Is it ethical to "source" items on Depop & resell for higher price? : r/Depop Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/Depop icon
r/Depop icon
Go to Depop
r/Depop

Welcome to the subreddit for the selling app, Depop. Please read the rules and the FAQ before posting. Unofficial/unaffiliated with Depop LTD.


Members Online

Is it ethical to "source" items on Depop & resell for higher price?

Discussion

I came across these viral videos about a Depop seller was selling $298 "rare" Forever21 shorts, similar to the Charlotte Russe ones that went viral a few weeks ago. This seller apparently "buys low, sells high." Example: buyers Hollister shorts for $10 from another Depop seller, and then resells them for $88 in their own shop. On one hand, it's a "don't hate the player, hate the game" situation. But on the other hand, it gives me the ick when the app was meant to feel like a community for circular fashion vs. arbitrage/stock trading vibes.

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options
u/AutoModerator avatar
Moderator Announcement Read More »

Is the same as sourcing from thrift stores and then reselling, ethical I don’t really know, everyone has different opinions about this. I think reselling, no matter where we source is more ethical than buying fast fashion made by underpaid & overworked people. Did those shorts sell for that price? Because people can price however they want, doesn’t mean it will sell for that price. That’s why we do market / pricing research based on sold comps & not on active listings for sale. Sourcing from depop isn’t the best / smartest way unless is an item with a very high resell value, because of the shipping & extra fees when buying, and then the selling fees.

Secondhand is definitely the better choice vs. buying new/fast fashion. After digging, it looks like the shorts "sold" for $198 (original list price $298), but others were saying that the seller may have just marked it as sold given the feedback they were getting on social media. Agree that it's not a long-term sustainable business strategy to source exclusively on Depop or any other resale app, unless it's a site like Helpsy, Bazaar, etc. that deals exclusively with overstock, low-priced items for bulk.

More replies

it's the same thing as going to goodwill for items to sell at a markup imo. i think it's lazy though to only find your stock through other depop shops, and money hungry to mark up something that much. people need the money and people do buy it

Very true! Sellers determine the *list* price, but that doesn't mean it *sells* at that price. Buyers determine the sell price based on how trendy the brand/item is, how the seller styled it, who the seller is even, etc.

More replies

As a reseller I don't agree with the amount they are up charging but I know resellers usually price higher bc people are bound to send offers, not only that but also in case it doesn't sell and they end up marking it down to 50% off they'd still make a profit. If someone buys some y2k f21 shorts at the thrift for 3-5$ I would see like 40$ max being a reasonable reselling price. The high pricing is gonna put off buyers and after all everyone just wants to buy what they feel is a 'deal!.

I don't support it, i see people do that with juicy and hustler, all these dif brands. They are dirty. I'll proudly sell my free people for 20$, which is half of what people pay for stained hollister shorts 😂

Continuing, i want people to be able to get what they want for reasonable prices on depop. The same goes with thrifting. I get making a buck, but like... there's a huge line.

I get that it's not against terms or anything, but it does change the vibe of the overall community.

Exactly, the whole point of second hand to begin with is for others who don't have the means to pay full price. I don't see why people feel the need to take advantage.

More replies
More replies

Look if I put something in my shop, I'm just glad it sold. If someone else is able to get more money for it then I did, then good for them I guess. Maybe they have built more of a following than me, maybe they are happy for it to sit around longer than I am, maybe they get lucky. I don't care. I sold the item for a price I was happy with, what they do with it is up to them.

Honestly I'm happy because my item sold faster and I don't have to store it anymore. If any resellers want to come buy out my entire depop shop, please go for it.

Idk it's kinda slimy to buy on an app and then repost in the same app for a big markup, kind of a don't shit where you eat situation, but it's not something I would waste my energy being angry over.

As a buyer I recall a seller who had a lot of a particular type of item I was interested in so i had a lot of likes on items in their store. Then one day they all sold and magically popped up in someone else's store for 3× the price. I was like really, this bitch 😠🤣

But i guess I had the opportunity to buy at a good price and didn't so who am I to complain. But yeah definitely never buying from that person even if I really want something.

Only if the price makes sense lol. I literally only typically see this with VS yoga pants and similar items that simply aren’t worth as much as people price them at. Don’t get me wrong you can get a pretty penny but people charging $120 for a pair of yoga pants are delusional. I’m constantly seeing a pair sold for say $10 on Mercari then they’re on depop for $100 the next week. Those are the people I’m judging. But if someone has a juicy bag listed for $10 and someone buys it and resells it for $80, at least it makes sense.

u/Plenty_Music3921 avatar

hustle is hustle at the end of the day. you’ll get people who will literally cry and rant about resellers ruining stuff and people who will back them up with all their heart.

but at the end of the day it’s not really a big deal, people just love to play victim to resellers cos they’re cry babies. it’s the people who complain about sellers selling for high prices and come on this app to whinge about it that are the worst. people need to shut up and move on with their lives. if you wanna have a good audience on depop, put in the work like the rest of sellers do and research and learn the market before you sell your clothes for below market value.

if you don’t like the price, don’t buy it is the way i look at it. ain’t nothing wrong with tryna make as much as you can with what you’ve got, if you don’t, you’re only ripping yourself off

u/Plenty_Music3921 avatar

depop was also never made to be a “community”. in an ideal world yeah it’d be great if it were like a homely market where we all knew each other, but at the end of the day that’s the way depop markets their business. it’s bullsh*t, and depop couldn’t care less about community or circular fashion, they want money and that’s their front to get people on board. all nice words yes but they’re there to benefit depop and depop only.

depop is in business to make money, their model works on the fact that users can “be their own boss” “have your own business” all that malarkey, but the reality is that it’s the same as any other selling platform. it exists to make money from its users.

More replies

Ethics are for you to decide. You need to find what you think is right within your core set of values.

There are so many unethical things in this world that we face every single day. Should I drink water out of this single use bottle? Should I drive my car that is powered by fossil fuels today? Should I buy food at the store that was grown in deforested areas and then packed in styrofoam? Should I eat seafood when the oceans are 90% empty and coral reefs and dolphins were killed to get the fish? These are things worth pondering the ethics of and losing sleep over. Other people buying something online and selling it for a higher price is not worth worrying about.

People can care about more than one thing! It’s crazy I know

More replies
u/belacinderella avatar

I think it's fine to do so, because it relies on a lot of factors to be able to do it. Influence, reach, a gullible audience (sorry). I know a prominent vintage dealer on IG who does this kind of buy low sell high but she has a lot reach in the community and a wide clientele base with deep pockets and some finds that went to high profile people, so she can get away with it, despite all the grumblings in the community. She sources from exotic places her clients can't get to (cool grungy places in CA and TX and often travels abroad) which gives her listings a certain ~cache~ and she describes the pieces so dreamily and models them so well that it really makes any piece enticing, even if it's not.

If Depop girlies are getting away with it, it's the fault of the people buying their overpriced nonsense, and if they want to keep profiting off people with less sense than money, then I say let them. It feels scummy but tbh if someone wants to pay $200 for F21 shorts, they deserve to be scammed. I wouldn't do it, but it's funny to watch.

Curation and styling can definitely "make up" for an otherwise basic vintage item, and warrant higher prices. At the end of the day, sellers can list for whatever price they want on Depop or any other peer-to-peer resale site, but buyers determine the sell price (if it sells at all).

Not sure why you are being downvoted for this? I know exactly which IG dealer you are talking about, but I never heard anyone whining about it, except one time when they posted a crochet outfit that was apparently not vintage. Anyway, I agree with you, if people spend time and energy upselling pieces, and the pieces sell, well that’s just how the market works.

u/Plenty_Music3921 avatar

people downvote what they don’t wanna hear

everyone wants stuff for cheap but doesn’t wanna do the work to get it lol

More replies
More replies