The Meaning Behind The Song: Why Don’t You Do Right? by Peggy Lee
Peggy Lee’s iconic song “Why Don’t You Do Right?” has resonated with audiences since its release in 1942. The song’s timeless lyrics and sultry melody continue to captivate listeners around the world, but what is the meaning behind the song? In this article, we’ll delve into the history of the song, its lyrics and explore its layers of meaning.
The History of “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
Originally written in 1936 by blues guitarist Kansas Joe McCoy, “Why Don’t You Do Right?” was first recorded by Lil Green in 1941. However, it wasn’t until Peggy Lee released her rendition in 1942 with Benny Goodman’s orchestra that the song became a hit, reaching number 2 on the Billboard charts.
The Lyrics of “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
The lyrics of “Why Don’t You Do Right?” are a tale of a woman confronting her man about his lack of ambition. The opening lines go as follows:
“You had plenty money nineteen twenty-two
You let other women make a fool of you
Why don’t you do right
Like some other men do?”
The woman questioning her man throughout the song points out his lack of ambition and blames him for their troubled relationship. The song’s lyrics are straightforward, with a clear message that resonated with many women during the 1940s.
The Layers of Meaning Behind “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
At its core, “Why Don’t You Do Right?” is a song about gender roles and power dynamics in relationships. The song’s female protagonist takes the role of a stronger, more assertive character, repeatedly challenging her male counterpart. The lyrics suggest that the woman recognizes her partner’s talents and potential, but she feels frustrated and disappointed that he is not living up to them.
However, many people also interpret the song as a metaphor for addiction. The opening line, “You had plenty money nineteen twenty-two,” refers to the stock market crash that led to the Great Depression. This line could also represent the beginning of the man’s addiction, a habit that has slowly eroded his finances and relationships over time.
FAQs
1. Who wrote “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
The original song was written by Kansas Joe McCoy in 1936.
2. Who first recorded “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
Lil Green first recorded the song in 1941.
3. Who made “Why Don’t You Do Right?” popular?
Peggy Lee with Benny Goodman’s orchestra made “Why Don’t You Do Right?” a number 2 hit in 1942.
4. What is the meaning behind “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
The song is about gender roles and power dynamics in relationships, as well as addiction.
5. What other interpretations of “Why Don’t You Do Right?” are there?
Some interpret the song as a story of a woman confronting her man about his lack of ambition.
6. How did “Why Don’t You Do Right?” resonate with audiences in the 1940s?
The song’s message of female empowerment struck a chord with many women during the time, especially with World War II creating a need for women in the workforce.
7. What other songs has Peggy Lee released?
Peggy Lee recorded many hits, including “Fever,” “Is That All There Is?” and “He’s a Tramp.”
8. What influence has “Why Don’t You Do Right?” had on music?
The song has been covered by numerous artists, including blues musician Bonnie Raitt.
9. What impact has Peggy Lee had on music?
Peggy Lee was a prolific singer, songwriter, and actress who won numerous awards throughout her career. She is known for her unique voice, sultry delivery, and contribution to the jazz genre.
10. Was Peggy Lee involved in the production of the song?
Although Peggy Lee did not write the song, she arranged the song herself, providing the melody and arrangement that she became famous for.
11. What has been the lasting legacy of “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
The song’s influence can be felt throughout pop culture, with references to the song appearing in movies like Who Framed Roger Rabbit and TV shows like Mad Men.
12. What can we learn from “Why Don’t You Do Right?”
“Why Don’t You Do Right?” reminds us to be honest with ourselves and our partners, holding each other accountable for our actions and potential. The song continues to inspire new generations with its message of female empowerment and self-determination.
Conclusion
“Why Don’t You Do Right?” has become a staple in American music history, with its message resonating with audiences for nearly 80 years. Through its lyrics, the song explores themes of gender roles, power dynamics, and addiction. The song’s unique combination of sultry vocals and insightful lyrics has ensured its place in music history as a classic.
