Who Is The Smiley Face Killer?

The story kicks off in 1997 with Patrick McNeill, a 20-year-old student at Fordham University. Patrick, an affable and outgoing young man with aspirations of becoming a teacher, hailed from a small town, embodying the quintessential All-American boy next door. One fateful February night, Patrick went out drinking in Manhattan with his friends, indulging in the typical college revelry. However, unlike his companions, Patrick never returned to his dormitory that evening. The following morning, he was simply...gone. Disappeared without a trace into the bustling streets of New York City.

Two months later, Patrick's lifeless body surfaced, floating face-up in the East River between Brooklyn and Queens. Authorities swiftly labeled it an accidental drowning, attributing it to a night of excessive partying. Yet one detective, Kevin Gannon, couldn't shake the feeling that there was more to the story.

Kevin, a seasoned NYPD detective, had been involved in Patrick's case from the outset. Despite initial appearances of a straightforward mishap, Kevin's intuition told him otherwise. As he delved deeper into the circumstances surrounding Patrick's demise, his suspicions intensified. Witness accounts from the night of Patrick's disappearance painted a troubling picture: sightings of him stumbling out of a bar with unfamiliar individuals trailing behind him, a peculiar scenario that didn't align with typical drunken behavior.

This detail, among others, gnawed at Kevin's conscience. Why was Patrick found floating face-up when drowning victims typically sink face down? And what about the anomalies documented in the medical examiner's report, hinting at possible foul play?

Kevin's persistence led him to uncover unsettling parallels between Patrick's case and those of two other young college men who had disappeared under similar circumstances in Manhattan. Lawrence Andrews, 21, and Joshua Bender, 19, had both vanished after nights of drinking before being discovered drowned in nearby waters. Despite lacking signs of physical struggle, their deaths echoed Patrick's, raising suspicions of a pattern.

Despite being reassigned to a different role within the NYPD, Kevin couldn't shake the unsolved mysteries surrounding these drownings. Upon his retirement from the force, he resolved to reignite his investigation, enlisting the help of his former partner. Together, they unearthed connections linking the cases to a broader pattern of disappearances along the I-94 corridor, spanning multiple states.

Their breakthrough came in 2006 when they joined forces with a criminology professor who had uncovered similar patterns in Minnesota. The discovery of a recurring symbol, a smiley face graffiti, near the locations where victims were found, hinted at a sinister network operating across state lines.

Kevin and his team, bolstered by this revelation, went public with their findings in 2008, exposing a possible connection between over 40 drowning deaths and the elusive smiley face cabal. Despite facing skepticism from authorities, they persisted in their quest for justice, advocating for a thorough reexamination of the cases.

Their efforts yielded a chilling realization: the smiley face killers, as they came to be known, were likely a coordinated group of serial murderers evading detection for decades. The discovery of additional victims and corroborating evidence only strengthened their case, yet official reluctance to reopen investigations persisted.

In 2017, the discovery of Dakota James's body, bearing marks of prolonged captivity and deliberate strangulation, underscored the continued threat posed by the smiley face killers. Despite mounting evidence, authorities remained steadfast in their denial of the existence of such a network.

As the story concludes, the smiley face killers continue to roam free, their reign of terror unabated. Only time will tell if the weight of irrefutable evidence will finally prompt authorities to confront the chilling reality lurking behind the mocking smile of their graffiti calling card. Until then, the threat looms large, casting a shadow over the safety of unsuspecting victims

Sources:

Inside The Disturbing Theory Of The Smiley Face Killer And Buffling Deaths Behind It

Who Is The Smiley Face Killer?