I thought it would be interesting to see what your favorite size of Pflueger Medalist is. I realize that the size depends on what line you're using and what you're fishing for, but if you had to chose a favorite to say "this is the peak of the line" which size would you point to?

I'm not including the 1300 or 1500 series, as they're sized equivilent to the predominant 1400 series.

So, again, the question is, which Medalist size is the one that you think is the sweet spot?

I believe the voting will pan out that way, as well.

Looks-wise, and collector desirability, I think a round-line-guard (pre '50) 1495-1/2 is the bee's knees.

The 1494 would work with the majority of rods I most often fish.

Have owned a few over the years but am 1494-less at this time.
I would really prefer a 1594 ... got one you would like to sell?

I've had every size but the 1492 and 1492 1/2 as these, despite the same name, are really a different reel and I just don't care for fixed click reels. The 1495 and '95 1/2 are great reels, too, but not so much for the mid-line weights. Same for the 1498, often used as a trolling reel back in the day. I bet if sales figures were available, the edge would go to the 1494, the ideal palm-of-the-hand midsize trout reel. That's all I have now, not even a 1494 1/2 anymore although it is a great DT 6 reel. viewtopic.php?f=4&t=11307&p=71423&hilit=assuming+you+use+RHW#p71423

I like clickers in #4/5/6 weights, and am LHW only;
so I voted for the 1495.

Great reel for #6/7 weights.

I prefer clickers for trout fishing but for warm water a Medalist seems just right (1495).

I have 3 1494s and a 1495 now, and if the 1494 would just take a full DT 5 with some backing, id be in heaven, and wouldnt need the 1495, as I prefer the smaller 1494's looks. All of mine are the rectangular line guard, Akron ones ... someday, Ill get a round guard one. A WF 5 or 6 fits on a 1494 fine, and I dont like the 1/2 sizes.

All are set up as RHW, and i will leave them that way, I dont mind switching hands to reel, I did so with spinning rods for many years. I havent had the chance to do anything but cast in a park near my house, as between the weather and work, time is tight. I managed to get 2 for 1 auction, and then managed to snag the other 2 with well-timed snipes; I dont think I spent over 100 dollars for all 4. Theyre not perfect, with worn paint and such, and my 1495 dosent click when the drag works, due to a stuck pawl, but theyre quite nice, servicable reels, and I dont imagine I will see any need to replace them. It helps that I simply love how they look.

I am looking forward to fishing with them, I will probably use the 1495 on my FF75, and 1494s on my others, plus a spare, I suppose.

Amanda

I bought a 1498 off eBay that is in verry nice condition. I have not used it yet but figured it may make a nice steel head or Saltwater reel someday.

Do you guys like RC models?

I have few but this one is by far my favorite. 1495 1/2 with new foot and balancer just works like a charm, i love this reel.

Did they ever make a model like the 1496 in lhw. I would love that size on 8 1/2' rods.

Barry

I voted for the 1494 but I also like the 1495 1/2.