Elden Ring (for PC) Review | PCMag Skip to Main Content

Elden Ring (for PC) Review

A magnificent RPG sullied by frame rate issues

3.5
Good
By Gabriel Zamora

The Bottom Line

Elden Ring is a wonderful action-RPG that features thrilling combat, an amazing open world, and tons of replay value. Unfortunately, its PC performance needs work.

PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Pros

  • An impressive, well-designed open world
  • Excellent combat
  • Many secrets and optional content
  • A lengthy game with great replay value
  • Fantastic visuals and aesthetics

Cons

  • Obnoxious stuttering on PC in testing
  • Balance and challenge feel arbitrary at times
  • Intrusive tutorial messages

Elden Ring (for PC) Specs

Games Platform PC, Xbox Series X, Xbox Series S, Xbox One, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5
Games Genre Action-RPG
ESRB Rating Mature

Elden Ring plays like a FromSoftware greatest hits compilation. This open-world, action-focused RPG is rooted in grim, Dark Souls-esque fantasy, but the game incorporates elements from all the Souls games to date, including Bloodborne and Sekiro. The result is a masterful experience that features melee and magic systems with a staggering number of RPG class builds, and horseback exploration that feels smooth, natural, and intuitive—a first for a Souls game. Unfortunately, this $59.99 PC game also suffers from intrusive frame stuttering. This can be a potential deterrent, or even an outright deal breaker. It’s a shame, because were it not for this issue and a few minor quibbles, Elden Ring would be a must-own title. 


Wandering the toxic wastes

Dark Fantasy Souls

Elden Ring is a Souls game, through and through. For the uninitiated, FromSoftware’s Souls games are action-RPGs with simple controls, brutally challenging combat, dark fantasy story elements and visuals, and a notorious corpse run mechanic that requires you to physically collect the valuable experience you lose whenever you die. Elden Ring takes elements from many FromSoftware-developed RPGs, as it features Dark Souls' sword and sorcery, Bloodborne's speedy movement and nightmarish imagery, and Sekiro's defense-heavy mechanics and jump-oriented action. It’s the culmination of everything FromSoftware has developed, married to a staggeringly massive open world that's dense with secrets, dungeons, and threats.

Our Experts Have Tested 165 Products in the Games Category in the Past Year
Since 1982, PCMag has tested and rated thousands of products to help you make better buying decisions. See how we test.

A Sprawling Fantasy World

Every Souls game gets love in Elden Ring, even the black sheep of the series, Dark Souls II. In fact, Elden Ring feels like the realization of everything Dark Souls II promised it would be when it was first revealed. It features a grandiose story, a sprawling and highly detailed world, superb lighting elements, and spectacular visuals and vistas. Dark Souls II had fleeting glimmers of that inspirational vision in places like the Dragon Aerie and the Shrine of Amana, but all too often the game world felt generic and even nonsensical.

In Elden Ring, every zone has the same spectacular flair and evocative wonderment as the Dragon Aerie in Dark Souls II. From the lighting and shadows to the mist hanging over highlands, Elden Ring looks awesome in the most literal sense. Jaw-dropping monuments and fantasy architecture add to the graphical splendor, too. On the whole, Elden Ring is easily the most visually impressive game that FromSoftware's produced.

Similar Products

Baldur's Gate 3
5.0
Exemplary

Baldur's Gate 3

Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII Reunion (for PC) Image
4.0
Excellent

Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII Reunion (for PC)

Dark Souls II (for PC)
4.0
Excellent

Dark Souls II (for PC)

Dark Souls III (for PC)
4.0
Excellent

Dark Souls III (for PC)

Deus Ex: Mankind Divided (for PC)
4.0
Excellent

Deus Ex: Mankind Divided

Diablo IV Image
4.0
Excellent

Diablo IV

Disco Elysium - The Final Cut (for PC) Image
4.5
Outstanding

Disco Elysium - The Final Cut (for PC)

Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade (for PC) Image
4.0
Excellent

Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade (for PC)

Final Fantasy X/X-2 HD Remaster (for PC)
4.5
Outstanding

Final Fantasy X/X-2 HD Remaster (for PC)

Genshin Impact (for PC) Image
4.5
Outstanding

Genshin Impact (for PC)

Hades (for PC) Image
4.5
Outstanding

Hades (for PC)

Honkai Star Rail
4.0
Excellent

Honkai: Star Rail

Horizon Zero Dawn: Complete Edition (for PC) Image
4.0
Excellent

Horizon Zero Dawn: Complete Edition (for PC)

Mass Effect: Legendary Edition (for PC) Image
4.5
Outstanding

Mass Effect: Legendary Edition (for PC)

Mass Effect 2
4.5
Outstanding

Mass Effect 2

Monster Hunter Rise (for PC) Image
4.5
Outstanding

Monster Hunter Rise (for PC)

Monster Hunter World  (for PC)
4.5
Outstanding

Monster Hunter World (for PC)

Nioh 2: Complete Edition (for PC) Image
4.5
Outstanding

Nioh 2: Complete Edition (for PC)

Persona 4 Golden (for PC) Image
5.0
Exemplary

Persona 4 Golden (for PC)

Persona 5 Royal (for PC) Image
4.5
Outstanding

Persona 5 Royal (for PC)

Record of Lodoss War: Deedlit in Wonder Labyrinth (for PC) Image
3.5
Good

Record of Lodoss War: Deedlit in Wonder Labyrinth (for PC)

Rune Factory 4 Special (for PC) Image
4.0
Excellent

Rune Factory 4 Special (for PC)

RymdResa
4.0
Excellent

RymdResa (for PC)