Pros and Cons of Negotiation and Litigation

There are several ways you may resolve a conflict with another party or parties, including litigation and negotiation. Choosing between negotiation and litigation holds significant implications for you and the opposing party. While negotiation offers flexibility and informality, litigation presents a formalised legal process. This article will explain the key distinctions between the two, as well as the pros and cons you should consider when resolving a dispute. 

What are Negotiation and Litigation?

Negotiation is an adaptable and informal dispute resolution method where you conduct strategic discussions with another party or parties. This allows you to reach a mutually acceptable resolution. Negotiation is both voluntary and non-binding, allowing you to attempt and come to an agreement independently without the involvement of a third party. Negotiation can occur in several forms, including:

• face-to-face meetings;
• phone conversations; or 
• written correspondence such as emails or letters. 

Litigation is typically considered when all alternative dispute resolution methods have been exhausted, and the dispute is taken to court. This means that your dispute follows a structured process in the court and will rely on a judge to determine a binding resolution. Litigation is thus more formal, giving you the opportunity to present your case in a legal setting and seek more compensation (usually in the form of damages). 

Guide to Resolving Business Disputes

This guide provides key information on how to manage a business dispute as quickly and cost-effectively as possible.

Download Now

The Pros and Cons of Negotiation 

Negotiation, as a type of alternative dispute resolution, tends to be more approachable and flexible. However, you should also be aware of some key concerns that may be relevant depending on how complex your issue is. The pros and cons of negotiation are explained below. 

Pros of Negotiation

The first key benefit of negotiation is that it is more flexible. When conducting a negotiation, you can customise and shape terms to your specific needs and preferences to resolve the dispute. For example, you may suggest a term that ensures all parties involved are able and willing to participate in the negotiation. This flexibility can increase your chances of reaching a satisfactory agreement.

Negotiation also preserves and strengthens the relationship between you and another party. This is especially so if you reach an agreement. Finding common ground and demonstrating a willingness to compromise can encourage trust and collaboration.

Furthermore, negotiation can lead to increased creativity when resolving a dispute. You are encouraged to find innovative solutions that meet your needs. At the same time, you are also compelled to consider the other party’s/parties’ interests. It can be a powerful strategy to achieve a better outcome for yourself as it provides you with an opportunity to create an agreement that reflects your interests. 

Considering costs, negotiation allows parties to address their concerns and reach agreements in a more streamlined and efficient manner. This may reduce your legal costs. Negotiation can promote quicker dispute resolution by allowing more flexible options, minimising the delays commonly associated with court proceedings.

Cons of Negotiation

However, a negotiation may not always occur on an equal playing field. Power imbalances can lead to one party having a significant advantage, potentially resulting in an agreement that is unfair to you. The absence of a neutral third party may encourage another party to attempt to take advantage of you.

You may encounter an impasse when negotiating. This can cause frustration and waste time. Importantly, you should note that no party can be compelled to continue negotiations, allowing any party to terminate the process at any stage. This is regardless of the time, effort, or resources you or other parties have invested.

Lastly, even if you reach an agreement, enforceability can be a challenge. This is particularly so if the negotiated terms are not legally binding or if one party fails to uphold their end of the bargain. 

Summary of Pros and Cons of Negotiation

Pros and Cons of Litigation 

The formalised processes involved in litigation can be appealing, but you should understand why litigation may not be suitable for your issue. These pros and cons are outlined below. 

Pros of Litigation

Litigation usually results in a final judgment or order. This is a clear resolution that leaves no ambiguity. It provides you and the other party/parties clarity on each other’s:

• rights;
• obligations;
• legal consequences; and
• remedies.

Court judgments are legally binding, and the court has the authority to enforce its decisions to all parties involved. This can provide a sense of finality and security to you if your case prevails.

When courts make decisions, they set a guide for how the law should be applied in the future. This means you can learn from past decisions in similar cases, making it easier for you to argue your point.

Additionally, litigation can hold individuals or companies accountable in the public eye. Court proceedings are generally a matter of public record. Such transparency can contribute to accountability and discourage unfair and unethical practices. It can also send a strong message that you and your business are not to be taken lightly. This can deter other parties from engaging in future disputes.

Cons of Litigation

On the other hand, legal proceedings are often costly and time-consuming. This can cause you and other involved parties frustration and stress. Time-wise, there may be delays in obtaining a court date. This creates added costs on top of the high expenses already associated with litigation, such as legal fees and court costs. 

Litigation can also challenge professional and personal relationships. This is because a court hearing results in a judgment that ultimately favours one party over the other. It is important to consider if you would like to maintain the relationship with the other party.

Another issue to consider is that once a case goes to court, you will have limited control over the proceedings. The court dictates the timeline, and you may have to adhere to formal rules and procedures.

Finally, court proceedings are generally open to the public. Details about your case may also become publicly accessible. This exposure can be a concern if you are looking to maintain your privacy.

Summary of Pros and Cons of Litigation

Key Takeaways

Negotiation and litigation resolve your dispute in different ways, but can be equally as useful. It is important to consider the nature of your issue, and ensure that the dispute resolution method you choose can meet your aims. Negotiation provides you with the opportunity to discuss the concerns surrounding the dispute and attempt to come to an agreement that all parties are happy with. This is generally a more flexible and communicative process but does not guarantee binding agreements. Alternatively, litigation involves settling disputes within the legal framework, where the consequences of the outcomes are legally binding for you and the other party. It gives you a clear resolution to your issue, but can be costly, lengthy and harmful to your relationship with the other party. 

If you would like assistance regarding which dispute resolution method to adopt, our experienced dispute resolution lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 1300 544 755 or visit our membership page.