What’s the darkest joke in the show? : r/howyoudoin Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/howyoudoin icon
r/howyoudoin icon
Go to howyoudoin
r/howyoudoin

A subreddit for fans of the popular hit TV sitcom, Friends.


Members Online

What’s the darkest joke in the show?

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options

Joey being molested by his tailor for years

"That's how they do pants!"

Yeah IN PRISON

More replies
u/NadaKD avatar

That was my first thought too

I immediately thought of this too. Funny how it also means it's a good joke, lol

More replies

You have to stop the Qtip when there’s resistance.

If you stopped the laugh track, that's dark.

It’s dark regardless. He had been seeing this tailor since he was 15 (wait, no 16, wait, no, he was 15. Ok when was 1990?) so it had been going on for a long time. I’m a woman and I’ve had pants altered a few times and when they measure the inseam and go all the way up they do graze the crotch area briefly. That said, I honestly don’t know what a tailor does to pants to size them properly but I’d imagine balls do get in the way? But cupping them and moving them seems like it’s unnecessary. Maybe a man who has had pants altered can chime in here.

Absolutely but I think the laugh track in dark moments within sitcoms can be used to distract from how dark a moment can actually be. So the effect is "this is dark but funny" vs "this is disturbing" same effect can be said when Ross gets mad about his Thanksgiving sandwich being taken and the laugh track comes in but if you remove that, it's actually pretty scary to see Ross that unhinged.

Oh yeah I’ve watched some scenes with the audience laughter removed and it’s pretty funny how easily this can go from comedy to dark drama at times.

More replies

Chiming in to say I love the way you write. Seriously, I want to read everything; send me your shopping lists. Also yeah, super messed up, poor Joey

That’s so sweet of you to say! I’d say feel free to read my comment history but most of it is nonsense with the rare exception of some advice for people going through various medical issues because I’ve experienced them myself. But yeah, have at it.

I need eggs, whole wheat bread, romaine lettuce (chopped, not a full head, I’m not a chef), salted butter (unsalted butter is just grease), kosher salt, turkey (again, sliced because I’m still not a chef), provolone (see previous comments about not being a chef), mayonnaise, baby carrots, ranch dressing, borax, sponges (the yellow and green kind, not the lame ones without a scrubby side), coffee (light roast, ground), cat food (fancy feast pate because my cats are spoiled brats and just lick the sauce off of the regular wet food leaving the actual chunks of food behind), paper towels. I think that’s it for now! Cash tip if you bring to my door, 4th floor walk up.

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies

And one of the funniest scenes of the entire series.

More replies

The little Girl Scout who was selling cookies so she could go to space camp. Her dad gambled her college fund away and would likely lose her bike if she won second prize, and then Ross broke her leg.

u/Pants3InchesShorter avatar

“I’m an honorary brown bird member. It means I can sell cookies, but I’m not invited to any sleepovers”

u/a_vaughaal avatar

What a scrud!

u/KittyConfetti avatar

Why don't look in the mirror scrud! her sass is next level

u/a_vaughaal avatar

Makes me laugh every time 🤣

more reply More replies
More replies
More replies

Her?

not pictured

u/dude-lbug avatar

Wait what? Space camp girl was egg from arrested development??

Yes. She was the very same one with the Holy Eternal Rapture (H. E. R.)

More replies
More replies
u/SquirrelLuvsChipmunk avatar

Egg?

More replies

Yeah, that little girl's life sucked... I hear she had a brief fling with George Michael though, which seems weird

Then almost got married to Gob

More replies

Dad loves the slots.

u/UncensoredSmoke avatar

Such a ross moment

u/Baron_Butterfly avatar

What a scrud.

I still call my husband this when he’s pissing me off

More replies
More replies
u/SaMisterek avatar

Dad loves the slots!

More replies
More replies

The entire suicide plot with Jason Alexander.

"...is that because you ran out of toner?"

u/MeasurementEvery3978 avatar

what is toner?

More replies
More replies

The joke of him on the phone and phoebe asking if he was busy, and he turns to his white board with “todays to do list: kill yourself” gets me every. Single. Time.

u/DifficultMinute avatar

I always loved how he said “How?” when asking how Phoebes mom killed herself.

Such a great line.

u/night_glitter avatar

And then her retort “I’m not gonna give you tips!” I say that often (though not in this context).

More replies
More replies
u/Background-Time4794 avatar

“... chandler?“

u/moejoereddit avatar

This is the one I was looking for. My favourite joke of the whole show

More replies
u/Ok-Syllabub-1864 avatar

All he needed was some serenity now

Serenity now. Insanity later.

More replies
u/tonyhasareddit avatar

Was that wrong? Should they not have done that? 😂

Nice. I use the "was that wrong?" quite often after obvious wrong behavior and I'm concerned that nobody gets the reference.

u/tonyhasareddit avatar

I use it way too much too lol. Unfortunately, the number of people that get my Seinfeld - and Friends for that matter - references in real life these days is getting smaller as time goes on.

more reply More replies
More replies
More replies

The whole universe cares!

u/littlrkinder avatar

She should know, she has the whole world on her shoulder.

More replies
u/NadaKD avatar

What was that? I can’t remember

It’s the episode where Phoebe finds herself on the phone with a man planning to kill himself because literally no one even knows he exists, then goes to where he works to try and dissuade him.

He asked how her mom killed herself and she’s like “I’m not gonna give you tips!”

u/NadaKD avatar

Yes that’s right. It is too dark.

More replies

When Phoebe was selling the toner online

u/Specific_Till_6870 avatar

On the phone

u/NadaKD avatar

Oh yes

More replies
More replies

Why isn’t this the top comment

It is now lol

More replies
More replies
u/FranFace avatar

"Come on, by that age, kids have already seen orgies. ... No? Just me??"

😬

yes! everyone talks about phoebes messed up childhood but chandler had a lot of trauma too.

[deleted]
[deleted]

Comment deleted by user

Mostly? Her mother committing suicide, her step dad going to prison, and being homeless are pretty traumatic and real things.

My favorite part of that Pitch Meeting episode, she's a very trauma filled individual, "Nah, she's the quirky one"

A pimp spit in her mouth. That's pretty rough.

More replies
u/Ill-Inspector7980 avatar

I don’t think they’re myths. I think even Denise existed. None of them ever go hang out at her place. I think she intentionally didn’t tell them all about Denise and then accused them of not listening to her.

I believe that she stabbed a cop. She robbed Ross and even knew the guy who was going to rob Ross when they were adults. She has skirted the law a lot. Even Gary says that her file shows that she’s done a lot of shady things.

I even believe the Prague thing. She probably went as an au pair, maybe learned how to be a masseuse there. Lived 6 months and probably got deported, even.

I love the Prague theory!

more replies More replies
More replies

I don't know, I completely believe that she stabbed a cop.

WHAT HE STABBED ME FIRST

more replies More replies
More replies
u/Putrid-Cupcake-1547 avatar

I heard about one theory that she is or used to be a spy. That’s why she has all those crazy stories.

more replies More replies
More replies
u/mopeywhiteguy avatar

What’s the context here? I don’t remember this

u/FranFace avatar

I think it's when he's filled the Ms Pac-Man scoreboard with rude words and Monica's stressing about clearing it off before Ben gets there.

More replies
More replies
u/5lash3r avatar

Idk if 'dark' is the right word, but when Phoebe goes on a date with that creepy guy before meeting Parker:

"I write erotic novels for children."

Like... Yikes.

u/LaikaZhuchka avatar

"They're WILDLY unpopular! 😃"

I fucking loved that character.

u/5lash3r avatar

me too lmao. almost everything he said was hilarious. idk if my humor is regressive to like a 4th grade level but the 'PHD' line slays me, especially because they use that same joke backwards in another episode with one of Rachel's sisters.

And those breasts.. mmhh!!

More replies

You know he's on a watchlist somewhere.

u/5lash3r avatar

oh shit maybe he was the guy at Emma's beauty pageant who came without a kid >.<

More replies
More replies

I always felt Joanna getting hit by a car and killed was really dark. Like it just came so out of left field. Also Ross and Monica finding out they unknowingly made out is really dark to me like, I don’t even find it funny it just makes me feel ill 😭 moreso than Ross and his cousin

what if sophie actually killed joanna and she just acted like she knew about joanna when she arrived at the office? 😭

"I sure did... because it was meeeee"

OMG yessssss lolol

u/CaramellieCake avatar

I loooooved poor bullied Sophie and her outright glee at that hag's death!😅

More replies
More replies
More replies
u/brinz1 avatar

I thought the whole Ross kissing Monica thing was way darker because Ross saw a drunk sleeping girl and decided to kiss her.

The fact it was Monica just made him look like an incestual creep

because Ross saw a drunk sleeping girl and decided to kiss her.

Omg I hadn’t even thought of it like that, you’re so right. That whole plotline should’ve never happened 😭

To be fair, he was just going to give her a kiss on the forehead.

Ngl, as a woman, if I found out a bloke had kissed me on the forehead while I was passed out drunk, I’d find and batter him. I don’t care how innocent it is to him, don’t kiss me anywhere without consent.