All but the smallest countries have regions. Few have a region of such historical and mythological import as the West does in the United States. No wonder, then, that the largest and most powerful film industry in the history of cinema developed a genre dedicated solely to the region. No wonder that this genre became America's most popular during its long mid-century heyday. Small wonder that the genre collapsed in on itself during the same era when the entire American project became attenuated and dubious. And yet, the West -- as a place, a concept, or a constellation in the social imaginary -- continues to beguile and intrigue us.Thriving on physical sensation, wedded to violence, dominated by the need for domination, and imprisoned by its own heroic code, the Western appeals finally beyond all these to whatever it is the high-up hills betoken.
- Jane Tompkins, West of Everything: The Inner Life of Westerns
Goal:
Watch Westerns. Discuss them.
Rules:
- I leave eligibility up to the discretion of participants. I ask only for good-faith submissions. Please be mindful that not every movie set in a Western state or featuring some tropes typical of the Western is truly a Western.
- Challenge runs from May 1, 2024 to May 31, 2024.
- A feature film (at least 40 minutes) counts as one point.
- 80 minutes of short films or miniseries/TV episodes count as one point.
- Films must be watched one at a time, at single speed (not sped up), and in their entirety.
- Not a rule but a request: When you post what you have watched, please include your reaction or at least a rating so that other people can learn about movies they might not know about. Also, the challenge is more fun and interesting when discussion is ample.
Stats & Formatting:
- Title (Year) is the preferred format.
- Don't edit posts to include new movies you've watched. Always make new posts.
- Please note that I will be traveling for the first two weeks of May. There will be few or possibly no updates of the leaderboard until I return home.
Previous Editions:
2012 - Led by sushantv10 with 84 points.
2013 - Led by sushantv10 with 30 points.
2014 - Led by Kasparius with 46 points.
2015 - Led by Chemosh6969 with 57 points.
2016 - Led by PUNQ with 113 points.
2017 - Led by PUNQ with 189 points.
2018 - Led by RogerTheMovieManiac88 with 85 points.
2019 - Led by PUNQ with 157 points.
2020 - Led by PUNQ with 86 points.
2021 - Led by PUNQ with 342 points.
2022 - Led by PUNQ with 206 points.
2023 - Led by PUNQ with 110 points.
Official Lists:
BFI's 100 Westerns
The Spaghetti Western Database's Essential Top 50 Films
IMDb's Western Top 50
Bonus Challenge -- Blocho's Recommendation
Watch The English. Here's my review from last year's challenge:
Spoiler
He also loves a vibrant and colorful Western landscape. All of you who dislike desaturated cinematography will be happy with this series. The landscapes are some of the most gorgeous I’ve ever seen in a Western. A little too gorgeous. These look like composite shots, with the sky and background layered in. We’re miles away from traditional studio sets.
Our story concerns the aforementioned Englishwoman and a Pawnee man, a former cavalry scout. These two heroes traverse a slice of the Great Plains (from Oklahoma up to Wyoming) in 1890, finding a constant array of bandits, ranchers, lawmen, Indians, and migrants. Most of them are deadly. All of them are desperate. As the Englishwoman says in one episode while recounting just a couple of the killings she’s witnessed in her short time in the West, “There’s just something about this country.” This is an exploration of the Western as epic, a vast historical and social canvas. We will hear about the Dawes Allotment Act, about the Land Rush of 1889, about the new germ theory of disease, and about bloody incidents like the Fetterman Fight and the Sand Creek Massacre. There are complicated narrative turns, sharp dialogue, and philosophical musings. There’s even a game of cricket.
Everyone in this series speaks obliquely. Instead of saying someone likes scalping her enemies, she’s described as “partial to lifting our hair.” I love this kind of dialogue, though the conversations occasionally wander a bit too aimlessly. The Pawnee character’s development is never fully realized. And there’s a bit too much preoccupation with physical deformity. Those are the only faults I can find here. In all other regards, The English is excellent.
And the score is great too.
Rank | Participant | # of Points | The English |
1 | RogerTheMovieManiac88 | 50 | --- |
2 | gunnar | 37 | --- |
3 | PUNQ | 28 | --- |
4 | sol | 23 | Partially |
5 | silga | 17 | --- |
6 | ororama | 12 | Yes! |
7 | frwnk | 11 | --- |
8 | frbrown | 10 | --- |
9 | Simba63 | 9 | --- |
10 | jdidaco | 6 | --- |
10 | blocho | 6 | --- |
12 | Lonewolf2003 | 5 | --- |
13 | FilmWalrus | 4 | --- |
13 | Melvelet | 4 | --- |
15 | AB537 | 2 | --- |
15 | Minkin | 2 | --- |
15 | vortexsurfer | 2 | --- |
18 | VincentPrice | 1 | --- |
18 | Good_Will_Harding | 1 | --- |
18 | Obgeoff | 1 | --- |
18 | zzzorf | 1 | --- |
18 | hurluberlu | 1 | --- |
18 | peeptoad | 1 | --- |