Kevin Feige Originally Told Hugh Jackman ‘Don’t Come Back’ as Wolverine, Rejected Ryan Reynolds’ First ‘Deadpool 3’ Pitch for ‘Rashomon’-Style Film : r/MarvelStudiosSpoilers Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/MarvelStudiosSpoilers icon
r/MarvelStudiosSpoilers icon
Go to MarvelStudiosSpoilers
r/MarvelStudiosSpoilers
A banner for the subreddit

Production Leaks, Spoilers, & News for Upcoming Releases from the Marvel Cinematic Universe & Sony's Spider-Man Universe.


Members Online

Kevin Feige Originally Told Hugh Jackman ‘Don’t Come Back’ as Wolverine, Rejected Ryan Reynolds’ First ‘Deadpool 3’ Pitch for ‘Rashomon’-Style Film

Deadpool & Wolverine
Share
Sort by:
Top
Open comment sort options

“I said, ‘Let me give you a piece of advice, Hugh. Don’t come back,’” Feige said. “‘You had the greatest ending in history with ‘Logan.’ That’s not something we should undo.’” What ultimately got Feige on board with the idea of Jackman coming back was that he would not be playing the version of Logan/Wolverine that audiences grew to love in the various X-Men movies. That was also of interest to Jackman himself. His original iteration of Wolverine died in “Logan,” and he did not want to screw with that film either.

Reynolds revealed that he first envisioned “Deadpool 3” as a “’Rashomon’ story about Wolverine and Deadpool and something that they got into together, but told from three completely different perspectives. It was a way to make a large-scale movie in a very small way.” Feige turned down the pitch, although he added: “The truth is, I wasn’t even sure how to incorporate Deadpool yet. I was very much thinking about how to bring mutants and the X-Men into [the MCU], and I thought it needed to be more than just playing the hits. But the truth is, Ryan is an idea machine. So he may have pitched that to me, but he also pitched 25 other thoughts and ideas.”

More replies
u/DJistheNerd avatar

RASHOMON? I never in a million years thought I'd hear a Marvel movie let alone Deadpool with that kind of comparison what the hell.

Ryan doesn’t get credit for how creative he is

He’s a marketing genius too.

u/Kind_Ingenuity1484 avatar

He just a genius. Period.

u/New_Highlight1881 avatar

he's just a period

more replies More replies

Lol

More replies
More replies
Edited

His public persona is being such a goof, it's easy to forget he's also kind of brilliant

It's kind of wild after growing up with him doing Van Wilder and Waiting. I love all the success for him.

u/GTSBurner avatar

My friend, the dude was in relationships with Scarlett, Melissa Joan Hart, Charlize Theron, and of course Blake Lively.

more replies More replies

I first saw him in Two Guys, A girl and a pizza place. He's been like this since he hit the screen.

more reply More replies

2 Guys, a Girl and a Pizza Place for me

More replies
More replies

Didn't he sell his advertising agency for a billion dollars or something? He got credit from somewhere lol

u/whythehellknot avatar

Mint Mobile was bought by T-Mobile for a billion, of which he had a 25% share in. And before that he sold his gun company for like 500 million. He still has his marketing company.

Would "Aviation Guns" be Reynolds marketing rifles specifically to hunters in bush planes & helicopters?

More replies
More replies

Let's not get carried away here. Suggesting a Rashomon riff is about as original as suggesting Seven Samurai in space. It's the go-to suggestion for every project because Kurosawa is film 101.

More replies
u/seth_cooke avatar

The main reason I think they should make the movie about Cap returning Mjolnir and the Infinity Stones is because meeting the Red Skull on Vormir would be a PERFECT Seventh Seal homage. They could even replace the opening Marvel fanfare with the Scott Walker song. It absolutely exists in my head.

u/leafybluesy avatar

y’all complained about black widow because it was “released too late” then you constantly bring up this idea or the Cap “nomad” idea WHILE ALSO complaining that Sam’s captain america doesn’t get enough screen time.

The Feige quote is about him not wanting characters to return after strong endings. You’d think people would realize that he might have the same mindset for Steve Rogers.

Yea but that was before they started introducing characters nobody cares about

more replies More replies
u/seth_cooke avatar

It was an anecdote about how he changed his mind. We know that, because Wolverine is in the next movie. Doesn't really matter which one it is - he's in it, played by Hugh Jackman.

I think he's wrong about the strong ending though. Logan was a bullshit movie. Not because they killed him (fine with that) but because it was crap.

more replies More replies
More replies
u/seth_cooke avatar

I didn't do any of those things.

The Cap story is in high demand. They should consider doing it because it legitimately is interesting, but IMO it should be an animated Special Presentation and not a live action film. That keeps it from overshadowing Sam Wilson and also allows them to get pretty crazy with the content and sidestep anyone getting upset that "they brought back Cap". Nobody is going to feel that way about an animated feature on D+.

More replies
More replies
u/NivvyMiz avatar

It's a pretty common way of structuring a story

u/DJistheNerd avatar

Is it? I haven't seen the "same 20 minute event re-told several times" structure in a while. Would be fun as hell tho, not knowing who to trust, and it would lend itself to the cameo hit as Deadpool would be the one to add them in his retelling for a layer of manufactured drama

u/NivvyMiz avatar

I don't have anything against this structure but I generally like it when superhero movies go big especially if it a kind of last hurrah or rare opportunity like this.  As Ryan points out this a way of doing a big movie in a small way and I think I prefer the big way it seems like they went with, in this case

u/GGGGTW98989898 avatar

The Last Duel was kind of this style if you haven’t seen it

u/DJistheNerd avatar

I did and I Lover it. Scott is a Cinematic master

More replies
More replies
u/Mavoy avatar

Birds Of Prey was even advertised as "inspired by Rashomon" (which is just offensive to Kurosawa lol), so it's not even novelty for recent superhero projects. I'm sure Deadpool version would be more interestng, of course.

No it’s not, quit bullshitting lmao. It’s been done before, yes, but in no way is it common.

u/NivvyMiz avatar

It's always sunny did it, Batman did it,  people adapt Kurosawa pretty regularly.

u/Rhino-Ham avatar

Probably most long running sitcoms and cartoons did at one point or another. It’s very common.

I feel like the statements "probably 5% of shows and cartoons have done it at one point or another" and "it's very common" are mutually contradictory. Lmao.

More replies
More replies
More replies

Tbf it was a fairly common framing device in sitcoms for a while (and has been used in other movies too I'm sure I just can't think of any). All in the Family did it, King of the Hill did it, Fresh Prince of Bel-Air did it, Frasier did it. I'm sure a lot of people would be familiar with it if done in a Marvel movie just maybe not from Rashomon specifically.

The Last Duel was the most recent example I can think of.

Oh ok. I didn't see it but I remember hearing something about it at least being multiple POV.

More replies
u/REND_R avatar

How I met Your Mother & Arrested Development both did their final seasons this way, too

Even Star Wars did it in 2017

What episode of king of the hill did It? Legit curious

The one where Hank and the guys become volunteer firefighters and the firehouse burns down. They all tell the police chief a different self-aggrandizing version of how it happened.

Of course! Such a classic.. Bomhouer version was the best

More replies
More replies
More replies

Whats Rashomon?

u/NivvyMiz avatar

It's an Akira Kurosawa movie (based on a book) in which different characters tell the same story of a crime that took place.  The movie is structured so that you're essentially seeing the same 10-15 minute story over and over again, but since different people are telling the story each segment is dramatically different.

The gimmick has since been used many, many times over from major artistic directors to It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia 

There was also a segment like that in Batman: Gotham Knight, and it was different art styles for each view.

u/Kite_Wing129 avatar

And an episode of Batman: TAS called POV.

And there's a great movie called Vantage Point. The same story told from eight different perspectives, starring Forest Whitaker and Dennis Quaid.

More replies

I’m watching this film tonight and am going to go down the filmography of Akira Kurosawa. My autism is strong today.

u/NivvyMiz avatar

It's one of the best filmography's of all time.  I recommend you go off the beaten path of his samurai/period piece films and explore some of his Film Noir, like the Stray Dog and The Bad Sleep Well.  Also if you can somehow find it, Madadayo which which was his final film. Of course, after you do the greatest hits like Rashomon and The Seven Samurai

u/DJistheNerd avatar

You are in for a treat. Bless Kurosawa and his films fr

High and Low is a flawless masterpiece. His best film that sticks out from the rest of his already impressive filmography.

u/Mavoy avatar

I have to give a mention to Ikiru, a moving drama about a man in the autumn of his life who finds a new purpose. It was recently solidly adapted fot the West as Living (with Bill Nighy), it's a good remake but it's not as beautiful as the original. I love Kurosawa's samurai and crime films, but I think Ikiru is probably my favorite.

Oh and one of his last films, Dreams, another of my favorites. Inspired by his actual dreams and he had some wild ones. Imagine Vincent Van Gogh... but he's played by Scorsese (yup).

more replies More replies

Please also watch Seven Samurai.

more reply More replies
More replies
u/Puppetmaster858 avatar

The Halloween episode of Sunny about who got Dee pregnant is a masterpiece, that shit is funny as hell

u/LukeNukem63 avatar

I wasn't Spider-Man, I was Man-Spider!

more reply More replies
More replies

Thanks for that little bit of trivia, something I'll definitely have to look into! Your description immediately reminded me of one of the later episodes of Punisher Season 1, which did the same concept and it was awesome.

The hotel episode! One of the best.

More replies

Oh, After Party was like that. It was a good show too.

Ooh that would have been an interesting take

One of my favorite Rashomon style episodes of a show is from King of the Hill. It was "A Fire Fighting We Will Go." It was great seeing the from POV of Bill, Boomhauer, and Dale and hilarious seeing how they viewed each other and themselves.

Basically the Last Duel

Kinda like bullet train?

u/NivvyMiz avatar

I haven't seen bullet train, so I can't speak to it, unfortunately 

More replies
More replies

It's a 1950 film written and directed by Akira Kurosawa, who is one of the greatest filmmakers in history.

Rashomon is about three people who are discussing a murder, and have conflicting versions of events. It's fantastic, I need to watch it again.

More replies

Oh fuck, I was so confused, I read it as "Rushmore," and was expecting a Wes Anderson-style movie about Deadpool dating an older woman.

Deadpool dating Blind Al? You (don't) love to (not) see it...

More replies

Yeah that’s a interesting concept if they can pull it off.

u/petewilson1111111 avatar

Ryan has always expressed his love for classic cinema. This is on brand for him, remember the TCM debacle at WB

u/Logical_Parsnip_9042 avatar

Kurasawa is a big influence for many people who work in the film industry. Im not that suprised.

Not to be a downer lol.

u/DJistheNerd avatar

Trust me you aren't a downer. I'm actually studying Cinema Productions in College rn and have been on a lot of sets both indie and studio that claim to be inspired by Kurosawa, it's almost always for the better

More replies
u/Srtruelove avatar

Disney loves to throw around references to Rashomon. Throughout the marketing for The Last Jedi, they kept going on about how it was a Rashomon tale. 

An episode in Punisher ss2 did use the Rashomon structure though

That would have been interesting.

I'm sure he's talked about this approach ever since Deadpool 2 released.

Well… the Last Jedi had rashomon storytelling but we know how that turned out

u/DJistheNerd avatar

Ah. Very true, but I'm picturing a full on Rashomon story structure. Rather than little aspects of the rashomon story in a grander tale

More replies
More replies
u/RenterMore avatar

This quote also triple super duper confirms this isn’t the Wolverine from Logan

I mean, he also appears to play at least two different Wolverine's just in the last trailer though.

u/Iggy_Pops_Lost_Shirt avatar

What makes you say this?

u/naughtmynsfwaccount avatar
Edited

If u watch the original teaser with just Deadpool’s voice he says something like “excited to do this with A Wolverine”

It implies that Deadpool runs into multiple

The trailer also shows a scene where Logan slowly unveils his claws and Deadpool has a gun pointed at his head

Chances are they give Deadpool a gun that has bullets that can kill Wolverine and Deadpool accidentally kills multiple wolverines while trying to recruit one of them and there’s some kind of montage. Probably like the scene in The Simpsons where Homer keeps going back in time via the Toaster and it’s just Deadpool repeatedly shooting Wolverine

Most likey Deadpool kills too many wolverines, the TVA doesn’t like this and they prune both Logan and Deadpool

The one that gets pruned is the one that features in the movie

We don’t know that all variants are played by Hugh

more replies More replies

I’m saving this so then when the movie comes out, I’ll know who to credit for correctly guessing the plot

More replies

One Wolverine has claws coming out of his fingers, one out of the back of his hand.

Not to mention Patch in trailer 1 who may or may not be played by Jackman.

u/Joshdabozz avatar

Patch is either Radcliffe or Cavil imo

More replies
More replies
More replies