Should all resumes be boring and colorless? : r/resumes Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/resumes icon
r/resumes icon
Go to resumes
r/resumes

Get help with your resume! Please read the Wiki before posting.


Members Online

Should all resumes be boring and colorless?

Discussion

Every resume I see looks like the back of a pill bottle, just walls of text. I recently saw the ceo of yahoos resume and some other colored ones and they just looked full of life and more enthusiastic. Is it bad to add color or should I just submit a basic black and white resume? Thanks for viewing my post

Share
Sort by:
Top
Open comment sort options
[deleted]
[deleted]

It really depends on your industry. If you're applying for creative jobs such as marketing or design, and you have a typical resume that's bland looking you're likely not getting the job. On the other hand, if you're an attorney applying for a job with a colorful mash up, people will laugh at that.

Overall, the resume should demonstrate your value to the position. Sometimes it's by showing you can stand out from the crowd by designs and sometimes by content.

u/prestonsteger avatar

Not sure if this is accurate, but I've heard that "creative" resumes will get stuck down by the ATS. Is this true, false, or somewhere in between?

100% true. I am in the creative industry (graphic/web design) and my resume used to be super unique and colorful. I spent 4 months applying to jobs with zero feedback. I tried to submit my resume through a sample ATS and it only picked up on about half of the information and it was all jumbled. Some great advice I heard was to keep your resume simple (read: boring) and let your portfolio showcase your talent.

[deleted]
[deleted]

ATS?

u/prestonsteger avatar

Application Tracking System - a lot of companies use this system to filter through resumes based off keywords and other factors. I've heard that these systems have a difficult time interpreting creative resumes due to formatting and fonts.

[deleted]
[deleted]

I can see how that may be true, but I personally have no real insight here. Sorry!

more reply More replies
More replies
More replies
[deleted]
[deleted]

Exactly

In between. Older ATS can handle fewer design features, newer ones are a bit more sophisticated. Standard advice (currently) is to either stick to basic design features such as colors, lines and shading or to create two resumes: one for the ATS and one with more flair to hand-deliver to humans.

The more tables, graphics, columns, and non-text elements your resume includes, the more likely it will be to not appear how you meant it to after passing through a digitization process.

More replies

I disagree that you won’t get a job in a creative industry without a colorful resume. It’s certainly more appropriate but the most important thing is still that the resume is easy to read and it highlights the most important information. So many “creative” resumes forsake basic principles of a good resume for the sake of aesthetic appeal.

More replies

If you're applying online , 90% of first reviewers will never see a pixel of whatever "design" you add to it. You upload the pdf or doc and ATS extracts all the text so they can find and filter as they like.

Maybe if you get to interview stage, they may print out the actual document you sent and someone might see any colors or font choice you made in the first place.

That's why most templates you see now are very plain "walls of text", optimized to make it easier for ATS to process without you having to make a hundred corrections afterwards.

u/jon14salazar avatar

This is really helpful thank you

More replies

I recently saw the ceo of yahoos resume and some other colored ones and they just looked full of life and more enthusiastic.

first off, at that level, hiring isn't driven by resume as such.

second off, please don't compare yourself to Fortune 50 list, C level people, unless you're in that tier as well [and if you are, what the fuck are you doing here?]

The resume is supposed to get you an interview. It should quickly tell the reviewer 'I can do X, Y and excel at Z' towards the goal of getting an interview. Generally, the interview is where you can show that you're an interesting human.

u/prettypattyburger avatar

I tried for two months with a fairly simple fancy resume. I even applied for jobs that were beneath me. As well as jobs that were within and above my range. Over 150 jobs. It was ATS friendly and I had so many resume views. One of the companies that reached out just hung up in my face when I called back. Lol. I was questioning what the heck I did. Anywho... I'm going back to my plain resume.

It's not my fault that people say that they want color and simply reject it when they get it. It's corporate America. Just remember... It sucks the color and the life out of you. It would be a shock to get any joy out of a corporate job.

When I was doing HR I actually liked colored resumes. But the black and white were easier to read because at some point your just scanning them all to get to the next. Anyway... Just stick w plain. It's not because of ATS or key words. People like plain boring text. Black and white w no pictures. It really tanks. If I saw a resume that had large font and color I would be interested and try to get them to next round. Apparently that's just me.

I was working on social media content ... And boss likes a single picture and a small title above w his logo. That was it. He hated anything I put extra work into.

More replies
[deleted]
[deleted]
Edited

Mine contains colouring to highlight sections and skills. Also, I played with black and grey to write body parts. And I like it, I think it is not really boring this way.

https://www.reddit.com/r/resumes/comments/bd6ryq/share_my_template/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

And I don't care about what recruiters think about colors on resume (just print in grey scale man 😠).

u/jon14salazar avatar

I like that, it’s subtle but still makes it standout

[deleted]
[deleted]
Edited

Thanks. Citing a reply from the thread: "The use of color, when professional, is okay. When people go overboard with design and color it's when problems begin to arise."

So, when applying for non-creative industry just don't opt for creative formats. Using colors, then, is okay also for me. Why not? World is so colorful.

If you feel that your aesthetic matches the culture of the company to which you are applying, this might be an acceptable strategy. But often, your resume will pass through automated or human screeners who aren't the final audience. So, the question you need to ask is, will they understand you colorful point of view or will your resume never make it past the initial screen?

[deleted]
[deleted]
Edited

I'm not applying exaggerated colouring, just a dark blue for headings + some bullets and other two colors, black and light grey, and the layout is very simple without graphics or lines or tables that can break scanning. Some platforms use information from PDF resume to fill all the sections (registration-fill scanning software is related to ATS?) and I have to say that all info are parsed correctly, also the contacts, dates, locations, universities and years of experience are calculated correctly. Had problems in the past with other formats. If you keep it simple and you maintain consistent formatting you'll be fine. I understand that company culture is important, but most of the time it is just something they have to show to build their reputation, marketing or followers or social presence (through hashtaggy and plasticky posts and photos).

I worked at Coke HBC and they did not respect one of their good purpose. My brother worked for a services (gas, water, electricity) company for years. They were all about culture and good purpose. They respected none of these things with employees. Company culture is just something useful you have to know for the interview.

If for some reason human screeners do not appreciate it, that's their problem...they don't know what they are missing ¯_(ツ)/¯ ¯_( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)/¯ My new philosophy: next in line.

More replies
More replies
More replies
u/MsMetallian avatar

I like the summary part as is B)

More replies

First and foremost, don't compare your resume to that of a CEO. Unless you are applying for the position of CEO, you should be tailoring your resume to the position you are applying for in terms of design and content.

Now to your original question why things look like the back of a pill bottle. There's a couple factors to this. The first is that a lot of resumes get screened by algorithms. So if your fancy, colorful resume can't be read by the algorithm, it will just discard it as junk. You've just lost an opportunity.

Second, it's going to depend on the industry. If you're going into a more creative and arts industry, a little color is going to go over better than if you are going into an industry like IT or Medical. The more technical the industry, the less likely a little color is to help you.

Also remember that the purpose of the resume is to get you in the door. Color and fancy won't get you in the door anymore. Telling employers that you have the skills that they want is 100x more important than making it look fancy.

At the end of the day, make sure your resume is neatly formatted, lacks any errors grammatical/spelling or otherwise, and contains accomplishments rather than just what your job functions were.

If you really want a fancy resume, create one, do some leg work and figure out who the hiring managers are for the position you are applying to and reach out to them with your fancy resume. You should really do that anyways even without the fancy resume as it shows initiative.

u/DTheoAllen avatar

Focus on the content not the design. Subtle, professional color enhancements can be okay but don't go overboard. Design heavy resumes choke up almost every ATS available. Moreover, the resumes can be very annoying for recruiters to read and scan.

The only time I would ever suggest using a design-heavy resume is if you know for a fact the person making the hiring decision will see it and appreciate it. But even then it is a risk.

u/JustCameHereToBrag avatar

Depends on the color. It needs to show enthusiasm, not a lack of professionalism. For instance, I recently talked to someone who was going through resumes for a position they were trying to fill. One had “LOL” in it. It was immediately tossed in the trash.

But if you have a subtle joke in your resume that only experienced people in your industry might understand, that could work for you. Humor makes people feel good, which makes it more likely you’ll gain their cooperation.

Pro tip:

Blue font is a professional look that doesn’t take away from your document but still makes it stand out. (Think blue and black pens)

Shading doesn’t affect ATS. You can use shading to differentiate between sections and adds variation in your document. I prefer either a light gray or light blue. Always use light colors because when it prints (usually in black and white) and you have too dark of a shade, it can affect visibility.

I'm going to agree with others here and say it depends on industry. I was applying for traditional corporate roles so it was clean cut and no color, but then when i went for PM roles I added 'friendlier' text and more color.

Yes. Unless you are in a creative industry, your resume should follow standard formatting conventions. No one wants to spend time trying to work their way through a "unique" resume. You can use some color and shading, but don't invest time in design. With the exception of creative roles, no one is hiring you based on your ability to bedazzle your resume.

u/inflredditor avatar

I’m going to echo the ATS comments. I have been applying since last summer and have had a couple interviews. I did some research on ATS and found a tip to copy and past my resume into notepad to test if it was ATS friendly. Sure enough HALF my resume was gone. No mater how I copied and pasted I couldn’t get it to show in notepad. I had formatted a table to save space and this contained my skills and certifications and awards. I have spent about 3 days now creating a whole new resume that is ATS friendly and passes the notepad test.

[deleted]
[deleted]

I personally prefer a fairly “minimalist” style. I work in marketing and I hate that everyone has started including pictures and headshots and icons and all sorts of other space-consuming pointless crap.

Anyways, I generally stick to black, white and grey, however, I do usually pick an accent color to “freshen” things up and work it into the page styling (i.e., the bullet points, maybe a heading or two). On my current resume I’m using #89f4dd. I’ve gotten a lot of positive feedback on it

u/bicyclegeek avatar

I work in marketing. The only color involved in mine is a single color that I use for heading and subheading titles.

u/NorrhStar1290 avatar

Yes and no. In regards to colour, it comes down to design, which is made up of how easy it is to understand and how much it stands out compared to other CVs.

I've had to read through hundreds of CVs from applicants, and I will always try my best to understand the person from the CV (we don't use ATS).

If a CV is boring to look at, it makes me think that the person is dull and unimaginative. It makes them feel more like a robot and I am probably less likely to recall the CV later on.

If a CV is designed to make it easier to read, it makes my job easier and I will pick up more information about the person.

Don't go guady, just make intelligent subtle choices that aid in communicating your information.

u/AutoModerator avatar
Moderator Announcement Read More »