Lily's Cookies

I really enjoyed the cookies I recently tried from Lily's Cookies!  I ordered an Homestyle Cookie Sampler Box online which I picked up in person and it came in a very cute pink box.  The cookies were small but packed with delicousness and flavor. I especially liked the sugar and chocolate chip cookies. Their storefront has ample parking and is very aesthetically pleasing when you walk in.  They have hand sanitizer out front to use and all of their employees were wearing masks which I very much appreciated.  I can't wait to go back and try some of their more decorated cookies!

Lily's cookies saved me! They were able to make custom cookies in less than 48 hours and they look, smell, and taste amazing! Easy and friendly to work with. Thank you!

Such a cute shop! The workers were so kind and offered us samples. Loved the cookies and all the options.

Ordered several dozen of their jungle animals decorated cookies for a baby shower and every person marveled at the decoration and once biting into the cookie raved about how good they were. "Not overly sweet," "taste the vanilla" "icing is delicious. Plan on ordering more for baby's baptism. Absolutely the best decorated cookie and favor. Also bought some red velvet and carrot Whoopie pies and their raspberry crumble bars, kept those for me and my daughter in law.

I just noticed a cute little sign, "Lily's Cookies"
on McCullough, and decided to stop in.  OMG.   I am glad that I did.  It is a cute, clean, cozy, little bakery.  Everything looks so good, it is hard to choose.  An eclectic variety of cookies.  You can really make a gift arrangement, very easily.  I can't remember what the piece of cake, that I got was called, Something with coffee and chocolate chips and the best icing.   But I will be back.  What  a wonderful find.

Cookie Taste & Designs Are Phenomenal! If you need custom cookies, Lily's Cookies is definitely the place to go. I read the reviews on yelp prior to deciding on trying this place out. I saw that many complained about the staff being rude however that was not my encounter at all. What I did notice is that staff were busy designing cookies. Each and every person in the bakery may not have spoke to you because they are working so diligently on custom orders. That doesn't mean they don't care, they just have a job to do.

I completed my order online on a Saturday evening and contacted them the following Monday to make sure they received my request. The manager was busy when I called and a staff requested a call back number. The manager called me back promptly and was able to accommodate my custom cookie needs.

Finally, after much anticipation it was the day I was set to pickup the cookies. I arrived and pulled into a very small parking lot. Only about 10 cars can be parked at once. I went inside and was immediately greeted by a friendly staff member designated to assist incoming guests. The staff member that assisted me was very friendly and helpful. I had previously informed them of being military and the staff member forgot to include the discount on my order before I paid. In order to remedy the situation, she offered to refund my purchase and start the transaction over. However, I was worried about the money taking a while to go back on my card so I declined and offered an alternative. I asked if I could get a store credit for a future visit instead and she made me an even better offer. She allowed me to use the discount amount at the time of my purchase to pick out anything in the bakery that added up to that discount amount. It was such a nice and generous offer.

Everyone at the surprise party I threw for my babe's birthday loved the cookies especially the details. They really took the Lego themed party to the next level. Because I was so busy hosting the party on (June 15) I didn't get a chance to eat much or taste anything lol  but I did taste the cookies today (June 17) and they were amazing. I can't quite put my finger on the flavor but whatever it is, it's so good. Overall, great quality cookies at a reasonable price. **Checkout my pictures to be wowed at the great job they did**

I've been following their IG page and I think their cookies are so pretty!  I couldn't wait to try them.  

I stopped in randomly one day and I was so excited to be there.  There were so many people decorating cookies in front of me, behind the front counter.  

A lady asked if I needed help.  I explained that I was new but wanted to taste a few cookie options and maybe another tasty treat to get a sense of their offering.

The woman was a bit rude and off-standish.  I got the impression that she wanted me to hurry up.  I picked 4 cookies and 1 brownie.  And I left as quickly as possible because this woman was just not kind.

I was so disappointed in the cookies.  They look pretty but there is little taste.  The first cookie I had was actually hard so it was probably old.  The others just didn't have much taste at all. I don't understand what makes these popular besides being pretty.  The brownie was a bit better but none of it makes me want to go back to try again.  Very disappointing!

The cookies are amazing. It the homemade taste with none of the work. Almond Toffee crunch cookie is my favorite. It's a buttery cookie with love in it. I also like chocolate chip, red velvet, cowboy, and oatmeal raisin. I like that they are smaller cookie (not too small) because it's January and diet season it helps with portion control. You won't go wrong with these cookies because these are the cookies where you put them on a plate and act like you made them.

These Christmas cookies never disappoint and well worth the price.  You can't have just one.  So be sure to get plenty.  Also a thoughtful gift for someone you wish to thank.

Their cookies are super good my personal favorite is their peanut butter and snickerdoodle. Those cookies were soft with just the right amount of crunch. Their other pastries are good as well definitely satisfied my sweet tooth.