Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 Pickleball Paddle Full Review

Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 Pickleball Paddle Review

4

Key Takeaways:

  • The Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 paddle is a versatile tool suitable for all skill levels, offering a unique blend of control and finesse.
  • With its Quantum-CarbonFiber surface and X5 Honeycomb Thick Poly Core, the paddle provides a superior feel and enhanced playability.
  • The paddle’s sweet spot is generous, making it forgiving for newcomers while still powerful for seasoned players.
  • Available in both midweight and lightweight options, it caters to personal preference and playstyle versatility.
  • The stylish design and color options allow players to express their personal style on the court.

Weight and Color Options for the Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 Pickleball Paddle

The Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 showed up in my mailbox last month and immediately found its way into my hand and onto the court. There’s a lot of hype about the Selkirk Vanguard Line, which in all my experience is really top-notch. For the S2 specifically, you’ve got two weight choices: midweight, tipping the scales between 7.8 and 8.3 ounces, or lightweight, for those of you who like to dart around with 7.4 to 7.9 ounces of quick-strike precision. This paddle’s got a broad wingspan too— 15.75 inches tall and 8 inches wide, with a grip that’s just right at 4.5 inches long and not too fat around with a 4.25-inch circumference.

The first thing you’ll notice while striking a ball is that sweet spot—size 10, my friends—think dinner plate compared to a teacup saucer. The playing surface? It’s about the biggest you’ll find, so you can kiss those ‘oops’ moments goodbye. The handle? It’s got a relatively short measure there, for the control freaks in us who need that tight grip on the game. Plus, with the EdgeSentry guard, you’re getting a paddle that’s lean, mean, and not gonna quit on you when the going gets tough.

I really like Selkirk’s Quantum-CarbonFiber tech. It’s designed to add to the sweet spot that goes on for days and a feel that’s slicker than Teflon. Its core is X5 Honeycomb Poly – it’s like having a secret weapon that eats up vibration and spits the ball out with a soft controlled touch. And the grip’s the VANGUARD Geo Grip. It kept my hand happy while in marathon sessions on both cold and hot days.

While it doesn’t impact your performance directly, I like the color options. I found it hard not to feel a little cool in stealth mode with the black, or light it up with some eye-popping neon. There’s a flavor for everyone.

With its ample control, the Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 is my new court-crushing partner for doubles matches. You may want to compare to the Selkirk Amped line before pulling out your credit card, but for me, the S2 won the day.

Grip Size and Handle Length

8.2
Photograph image of a gold colored Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 Pickleball Paddle white background. Selkirk Vanguard S2 Pickleball Paddle Review.

Get the Vanguard S2 2.0 Control and stratagy

Tune up your control game with the help of the Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0.

I believe the right grip can make all the difference when seeking control—enter the Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 with a grip that feels like it was made just for you. With a grip circumference sitting cozy at 4.25 inches and a length of 4.5 inches, this paddle is a dream for players craving that perfect meld of comfort and control. No more slippage, no more blisters—just a pure, comfy grip that feels like an extension of your own hand. And the handle? Not too long, not too short, it’s the Goldilocks of pickleball paddle handles. Medium in length, it gives you the leverage you need for those power plays, without sacrificing any sweet, sweet control when you’re finessing those dinks. Whether your hands are big or small, or you play with finesse or power, the Vanguard S2 2.0’s grip is ready to be the silent hero of your game. Take a look at Selkirk’s website for more information on that.

Summary
Pros
Cons
Top Pick
1
Photograph of Selkirk Vanguard Invikta Pickleball Paddle in red and black
Selkirk Vanguard Pickleball Paddle Invikta
Check Prices
Summary
Elongated Handle, large sweet spot.
Pros
Length and reach
Cons
Length comes at the expense of control.
2
Selkirk Vanguard Epic Pickleball Paddle in red and black
Selkirk Vanguard Pickleball Paddle Epic
Check Prices
Summary
Emphasis on sweet spot.
Pros
Great all-around paddle
Cons
Jack of all trades, master of none
3
Picture of Selkirk Vanguard S2 Pickleball Paddle
Selkirk Vanguard Pickleball Paddle S2
Check Prices
Summary
Durable Polypropylene core.
Pros
Large Sweet Spot.
Cons
Sacrifices some power

Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 Play Tester Overview

8.4Expert Score
X5™ Honeycomb Poly Core and Quantum-CarbonFiber

Designed with Control in mind – a scalpel, not a machete

Value for Money
9
Power
7
Control
9.9
Durability
8.5
Spin Capability
7.5
Pros
  • Quantum-CarbonFiber face and X5 Honeycomb Thick Poly Core for enhanced performance.
  • Available in different weights and colors to suit any player's preference.
  • Designed with a large sweet spot and balanced weight for precision and power.
Cons
  • Higher costs might be prohibitive for some players, especially beginners.
  • If you prefer a long handle, the medium size here might not be the best fit.
  • Its emphasis on control may require an adjustment period for power players.

How Selkirk Vanguard S2 Paddle Performed on The Court

I shared the paddle with some of the other Pickleballologists. Please take a look at my impression compared to theirs below. As you can see, we rate it pretty consistently across the board in favor of control.

Serves
Dinks
VOLLEYS
Drives
Blocks
 
older pickleball player closeup
Lleyton’s Scores
4.0 Player
Serves
88
Dinks
95
VOLLEYS
90
Drives
66
Blocks
90
cool and nice pickleball player
Seb’s Scores
4.0 former tennis player
Serves
80
Dinks
93
VOLLEYS
92
Drives
75
Blocks
96
fishwrists Create a hyper realistic portrait of Mason Kelley a 0fb4b640 6afd 44e6 9f3f 13863014f215
Mason’s Scores
3.5 player
Serves
87
Dinks
95
VOLLEYS
98
Drives
79
Blocks
92

Spin

Spin for the win with the Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0. The Quantum-CarbonFiber face put the ball on a string and danced it exactly where I wanted it to go. The texture grabs the ball like a wall-walking gecko’s foot and adds a twist that’ll have your opponents’ heads spinning as much as your shots. Pair that with the X5 Honeycomb Thick Poly Core; you’ve got a recipe for controlled, spin-heavy plays. Slicing, hooking, and chopping, the Vanguard S2 2.0 has the grip to rip it right and keep that ball turning on command. See our post on spin for a deeper background on the subject.

I love this video to demonstrate exactly what spin can do for you

A near magic-like spin serve

Serves

Step up to the baseline with the Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 and confidently serve. This paddle is a serving laser beam, giving you the mass and balance to start every point with an edge. With the choice between a slightly heavier midweight and a swift, lighter model, you can dial in the perfect level of drive and control for your serve. The ample sweet spot ensures your serves are powerful and consistently accurate (I can’t emphasize that enough about this paddle). I reduced faults and increased pressure on my opponent. The Quantum-CarbonFiber face provides the additional benefit of a textured surface, so when you want to slice your serve or add a bit deceptive spin, you’ve got technology on your side.

I was able to really drop some serves in difficult to return spots with the S2 – beyond what is normal.

Sebastian Devereux

Dinks

The Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 turns the soft game into an art form. With its ultra-responsive Quantum-CarbonFiber face, this paddle gives you a tactile feel about precision. The X5 Honeycomb Thick Poly Core is my secret weapon, absorbs the shock and gives me the finesse I need for the soft, kitchen-sink warfare. The sweet spot is so big, generous, forgiving, and ready to turn those soft hands into points. Downright diabolical dinking.

Drives

There’s a trade-off between control and power and this paddle favors the former. The heavier version will help with driving, but make no mistake, accuracy is what it was built for. The Vanguard S2 2.0 is precision-engineered to unleash groundstrokes with a blend of speed, stability, and soul-shaking accuracy. If you bring plenty of power to the game already, this will help you land those close shots in bounds.

Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 Specs

FeatureSpecification
Skill LevelBeginner to Pro
Average Midweight7.8oz – 8.3oz
Average Lightweight7.4oz – 7.9oz
Height15.75″
Width8.0″
Grip Length4.5″
Grip Circumference4.25″
Sweetspot Size10
Surface AreaLargest
Handle LengthMedium (4.5″)
EdgeSentry™Low-profile, lightweight and durable edge guard
FaceQuantum-CarbonFiber
CoreX5™ Honeycomb Thick Poly Core
GripVANGUARD Geo Grip™
S2 Specs

Likes and Dislikes from our Pickleballologist testers

Likes

Lleyton – “Bullseye accuracy.”

Seb – “The control is great; I kept the ball in bounds. However, I like a power game, so I might not be number one in my quiver.”

Mason – “The 7.8oz 3-5/8in option was perfect for my smaller hands.”

Dislikes

Lleyton – “I miss the free and easy power of some other paddles.”

Seb – “I’m happy with a smaller sweet spot if gives me more power. This paddle isn’t that.”

Mason – “I get to play with it for free, but its cost will be a deterrent for some.”

Summary

My conclusion is that the Selkirk Vanguard S2 2.0 is a top-tier choice for pickleball enthusiasts, from newbies hitting their first dink to seasoned pros serving up spinning aces. It’s a marvel of modern engineering, boasting a finely tuned balance between spin and control that transforms every swing into a statement. Whether you’re looking to add finesse to your soft game with its forgiving sweet spot or dominate the court with well-spun precision, this paddle delivers. The blend of advanced materials like the Quantum-CarbonFiber face and the X5 Honeycomb Thick Poly Core provides a playing experience that’s both comfortable and impactful. With its customizable weight options and stylish color variations, the Vanguard S2 2.0 doesn’t just perform exceptionally—it also matches the personal flair of every player. After extensive playtesting, it’s clear this paddle is a game-changer, promising to elevate your play and enjoyment of the game. For more information on the entire Selkirk line, see our review here.

Strengths

  • Exceptional Balance: Offers a superb mix of power and control, allowing for forceful strikes and subtle plays alike.
  • Advanced Materials: Quantum-CarbonFiber face and X5 Honeycomb Thick Poly Core enhance feel and performance.
  • Versatile Sweet Spot: The forgiving nature of the paddle’s sweet spot is ideal for a variety of shots, from dinks to drives.
  • Customizable Weight Options: Available in both midweight and lightweight options to suit different play styles.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: Comes in various color choices, catering to personal style preferences.

Weaknesses

  • Pricing: As a premium paddle, it may be considered an investment, especially for beginners.
  • Learning Curve: Advanced features may take time for new players to fully exploit.
  • Handle Length: Players accustomed to longer handles may need an adjustment period.

Best Suited For

  • All Skill Levels: From beginners to professionals, the design caters to a wide audience.
  • Players Seeking Power and Control: Ideal for those who want a paddle that supports both aggressive and strategic play.
  • Style-Conscious Players: The design and color options will appeal to those who like their gear to make a statement.
  • Soft Game Enthusiasts: The paddle’s responsiveness is perfect for players who excel at the soft game and require precise touch.
  • Players Looking for Durability: Constructed with high-quality materials designed to withstand intense play sessions.
Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
Reviews
0a3a 08 22 selkirk vanguard power air invikta middleweight carbon fiber pickleball paddle 36117 1 l
Selkirk VANGUARD Power Air Invikta
Optimal For Power & Spin
See Lowest Price
Bottom Line
Tyson McGuffin’s weapon of choice.
Pros
Super agile and sexy looking.
Cons
The gutted throat is unforgiving on mishits.
Reviews
Full Review
gearbox gx5 control heavyweight carbon fiber pickleball paddle 34117 1 l
Gearbox GX5 Control Heavyweight
Wide Body
Check Prices
Bottom Line
Whisper quiet with outstanding control.
Pros
SST tech taken to its max capabilities.
Cons
Some might find it to have a dull feel on drives.
Reviews
Full Review
bdec 01 23 prokennex ovation flight lightweight hybrid pickleball paddle 33945 11 l
ProKennex Ovation Flight Lightweight
Cloud Cell poly core
Check Prices
Bottom Line
Perfect for ex-tennis players.
Pros
Light and super duper spinny.
Cons
The Oval shape takes some getting used to.
Lleyton Howard
Pickleballogist
Logo