Elaine Barrie -- fourth wife of John Barrymore
SF Gate LogoHearst Newspapers Logo

Elaine Barrie -- fourth wife of John Barrymore

By , New York Times

Elaine Barrie, fourth wife of the Shakespearean actor John Barrymore, with whom she shared a tumultuous on-again, off-again engagement and marriage that enthralled the nation in the darkest days of the Depression, died Saturday in Manhattan. She was 87.

Her story unwinds like an old-fashioned movie. As a Hunter College student of 19, she wrote an adoring letter to Barrymore, then 53 and hospitalized in Manhattan. He phoned her, they had a pleasant talk and he invited her to visit him. There was a most meaningful kiss in his hospital room.

They almost immediately became known by the Shakespearean names they gave each other, Ariel and Caliban, from "The Tempest." There was a mysterious voyage on Barrymore's yacht, a cross-country chase (with her pursuing him), an elopement and tender reconciliations after spectacular quarrels.

There were darker elements to the tale. Barrymore, one of the leading interpreters of Shakespeare in the 20th century, was by then reduced by alcoholism to reading his lines. Many speculated the young woman was using him to further her acting career.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

When Barrymore got his bride a role in a 1940 play, "My Dear Children," the most photographed, talked-about scene occurred when he held her in his lap and spanked her. And the best-remembered of her few films was undoubtedly the saucy short "How to Undress in Front of Your Husband," released in 1937 and still available for sale.

Elaine Jacobs, the daughter of a traveling salesman, was born on July 16, 1915. She first saw Barrymore in the 1931 film "Svengali" and vowed to marry him, a friend, Linda Herman, recounted. At 16 she won a walk-on part with a stock company that turned into a talking role. She wrote and directed plays at Hunter College.

Even before she married, Ms. Jacobs changed her name to Barrie because it sounded like Barrymore. She used Barrymore during her marriage.

She wrote a series of articles about her romance for the New York Mirror in 1935. In the first installment, she told of reading that Barrymore's marriage to the actress Dolores Costello was on the rocks and of "turning faint with exultation."

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Sandford Dody, who helped Ms. Barrie write her autobiography, "All My Sins Remembered" (Appleton-Century, 1964), suggested that Barrymore found her a breezy change of pace.

"It was easy to see why the aging actor, sick in a hospital and sated with strawberry blondes of Hollywood who were as bland as Wonder Bread, found this bright and wry little New York girl, with all her crust, a tasty morsel," he wrote in his autobiography, "Giving Up the Ghost" (1980).

After they married in 1936, they had at least four public separations, including one legal divorce they agreed to reverse. The first tiff, in which Mrs. Barrymore said her husband "roughed me up a bit," came 57 days after their wedding, on New Year's Eve. The final divorce was on Nov. 27, 1940.

The Barrymore family -- which traces its acting tradition to 1752 and is today most famously represented by Drew, the granddaughter of John Barrymore and Costello -- treated Ms. Barrie as a pariah. She was the first of John's four wives to use the Barrymore name professionally, and the first Barrymore to undress onstage.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Ms. Barrie appeared in radio, plays and movies at the behest of her husband,

but is credited with only one full-length film, "Midnight," a 1939 movie starring Claudette Colbert.

After the divorce, she remained part of the Hollywood scene and dated Errol Flynn and Ray Milland, among others.

She later ran a business importing straw baskets and handbags from Haiti. Last year, she sold at auction a silver pillbox once owned by her friend Marilyn Monroe. To help Christopher Plummer prepare for a one-man show on John Barrymore on Broadway in 1997, she showed him Barrymore's love letters.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Ms. Barrie was the only former wife to attend Barrymore's funeral in 1942. She never remarried and has no immediate survivors.

Douglas Martin