Writing Sex Into a Novel: Should It Be Included? - Writer's Digest Skip to main content

Should Sex Be in Your Novel?

Susan Klaus, author of commercial fiction, discusses the value and realism of writing sex into popular novels.

Should Sex Be in Your Novel? If you write romance or erotica, then, of course, the answer is yes. For children books, it’s a definite no and questionable in Y.A. and religious books. But what about the other genres like historical fiction, mystery, suspense/thriller, fantasy, science fiction, and even memoir? The fact is that no truer words were spoken than “sex sells.” A look at the longest running best sellers is proof. Fifty Shades of Gray didn’t make the list for the terrific writing, and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, while a great thriller, the readers talked about the violent rape and victim’s revenge that sent them in droves to buy the book.

secretariat-reborn-cover

Order a copy of Secretariat Reborn by Susan Klaus today.

Amazon 
[WD uses affiliate links.]

Sex is also part of the human condition, as natural as breathing, eating, and sleeping. For an author to exclude it entirely from his novel is not only cheating himself but also the reader. A healthy protagonist who doesn’t at least consider it comes off as unrealistic, a comic strip hero. So if the opportunity arises, sex should be in a novel even if it’s a subtle glance and insinuation, a tender kiss and romance, a steamy encounter, or as bad as a brutal assault. Sex gives the characters credibility, an opportunity to show their confidence or insecurity, their passion, jealous, joy, disappointment, or twisted thoughts. In the end, they betray their diverse humanity. The story then becomes equally character and plot driven, making it believable and interesting.

I’m sure some authors, agents and publishers will disagree with me about having sex in a novel but this is what I have learned from querying my readers. They want their emotional strings pulled, and sex can be the driving vehicle. It portrays the selfish, vindictive partner we love to hate, the rejected, down trodden lover, the wanting, having, or heartbreak of a relationship, or the euphoria of two soul-mates finally connecting. Think The Thorn Birds, the priest finally giving in to the girl on the beach. Every woman with a pulse climaxed after wading through that long story.

Another thing, readers can imagine a family’s sorrow with a murder victim, but few have actually experienced this dreaded dilemma. But most of us can relate to sex, the love and loss. A subplot with sexual tension brings life to the story and gives characters their character. Of course, the decision of how tame or graphic the scene can sometimes fall to the publisher.

No, I’m not a romance author but write in two different genres, fantasy/sci-fi and thriller/suspense and would never rule out sex in my stories. There might be pros and cons on this subject, but it’s something to consider when writing your next novel.


Writer's Digest Tutorials

With a growing catalog of instructional writing videos available instantly, we have writing instruction on everything from improving your craft to getting published and finding an audience. New videos are added every month!

Click to continue.

Art and Emotion

Art and Emotion

Every writer needs a little inspiration once in a while. For today's prompt, write about what happens when art inspires emotion.

Nicola Solvinic: Be Willing To Experiment With Your Story

Nicola Solvinic: Be Willing To Experiment With Your Story

In this interview, author Nicola Solvinic discusses the surprises along the publishing journey of her crime novel, The Hunter’s Daughter.

From Script

Making Your Life Bigger Through Comedy (From Script)

In this week’s roundup brought to us by Script magazine, “Girls5eva” creator and showrunner Meredith Scardino talks about tapping into and writing humor that is relatable, and “Masters of the Air” creator John Orloff discusses why the series is character-driven, not calendar-driven.

Where Is My History in Regency Romance, by Amita Murray

Where Is My History in Regency Romance?

Award-winning author Amita Murray discusses the challenges of finding and writing better representation in Regency romance novels.

Gretchen Anthony: Believe in Your Voice

Gretchen Anthony: Believe in Your Voice

In this interview, author Gretchen Anthony discusses how her personal year of yes inspired her new novel, Tired Ladies Take a Stand.

5 Unconventional Ways to Structure Your Memoir, by Gina DeMillo Wagner

5 Unconventional Ways to Structure Your Memoir

Award-winning journalist and author Gina DeMillo Wagner shares five unconventional ways to structure your memoir, including several example memoirs that use these structures.

Katee Robert: On Chasing Your Joy

Katee Robert: On Chasing Your Joy

In this interview, author Katee Robert discusses the process of writing their new romance novel, Blood on the Tide.

Writing and Revising Your Picture Book

Writing and Revising Your Picture Book

Get the tools you need to proceed from where you are with your picture-book project to where you want to go, plus more from Writer's Digest!

Creating a Sense of Place in Fiction, by Caroline Cleveland

Creating a Sense of Place in Fiction

Author Caroline Cleveland shares five techniques she's identified that help writers create a strong setting in fiction.