What To Watch If You Love 'The Sinner'

watchworthy
Updated May 17, 2024 35 items
Ranked By
386 votes
113 voters
Voting Rules
Vote up the films and television series that you know other fans of 'The Sinner' will love.

The Sinner kept viewers on the edge of their seats with its twists and turns, so it's no surprise that you’d be on the hunt for similar shows to watch after bingeing the entire series. Well, search no more, because this list has some of the best recommendations for movies and TV shows similar to The Sinner. 

Deciding what to watch after The Sinner really depends on your mood, but if you’re looking for more crime dramas, Sharp Objects is a mystery thriller that you’ll almost certainly love if you like The Sinner. 

Some other movies and TV shows like The Sinner in this list are movies like Zodiac, which centers on detectives trying to solve murders. Mindhunter is another good TV series that focuses on serial killers. Other good TV and movies recommended for The Sinner fans include The Killing, American Crime Story, and Gone Baby Gone.

With more than 40 million people visiting Ranker every month, we are able to offer you data-driven recommendations based on voting across thousands of film & TV polls.

  • The Alienist
    Photo: The Alienist
    1
    10 VOTES

    The Alienist

    This turn-of-the-century period drama series is a great selection if you're looking for an investigative drama series in a setting most are unfamiliar with when it comes to forensics and detective work after finishing The Sinner.

    A journalist tries to solve a series of murders in New York City in 1896.
    10 votes
    More The AlienistRight Arrow
  • Broadchurch
    Photo: Broadchurch / ITV
    2
    22 VOTES

    Broadchurch

    Fans of investigative crime dramas, like The Sinner, will love this British serial featuring a star-studded cast of some of the island's greatest actors. 

    Set against the picturesque backdrop of a small coastal town, Broadchurch is an enthralling British crime drama that masterfully weaves together elements of mystery and human emotion. The series follows the investigation of a young boy's murder, led by the unlikely duo of Detective Sergeant Ellie Miller (Olivia Colman) and Detective Inspector Alec Hardy (David Tennant). As the plot unfolds, the show delves into the lives of the townspeople, revealing hidden secrets and unexpected connections. Lauded for its gripping storytelling and exceptional performances, Broadchurch has garnered numerous accolades, including BAFTA awards for Best Drama Series and Best Actress for Colman.
    22 votes
    More BroadchurchRight Arrow
  • Zodiac
    Photo: Paramount Pictures
    3
    21 VOTES

    Zodiac

    This dark mystery film from the director of Fight Club and Gone Girl is the perfect choice when you want your fictional detectives just a little bit on the obsessive side.

    Zodiac, an intriguing crime thriller directed by David Fincher, trails the chilling path of the famed Zodiac Killer. Robert Graysmith (Jake Gyllenhaal), a cartoonist at the San Francisco Chronicle, becomes obsessively intertwined with the unsolved case. Alongside him are Paul Avery (Robert Downey Jr.), a bohemian crime reporter, and Inspector David Toschi (Mark Ruffalo), a seasoned detective. As they delve deeper into the cipher-laden letters sent by the killer, their lives become inextricably linked to this enigma. The film, based on true events, is a tense exploration of obsession, fear, and the elusive nature of truth. Despite its long runtime, each moment is filled with suspense and intrigue, keeping viewers riveted until the very end. Zodiac remains a compelling testament to Fincher's mastery of his craft.
    21 votes
    More ZodiacRight Arrow
  • Sherlock
    Photo: Sherlock
    4
    13 VOTES

    Sherlock

    Delving into the intricate world of crime-solving, Sherlock presents a contemporary adaptation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's beloved detective stories. With its clever writing and masterful performances from Benedict Cumberbatch as the enigmatic Sherlock Holmes and Martin Freeman as the loyal Dr. John Watson, this British television series has garnered critical acclaim and a dedicated fanbase. Amidst its four seasons, the show has earned numerous accolades, including BAFTA and Emmy awards. Each episode unravels a new mystery, keeping viewers on their toes with unexpected twists and turns, all while showcasing the undeniable chemistry between the lead characters.
    13 votes
    More SherlockRight Arrow
  • True Detective
    Photo: True Detective
    5
    26 VOTES

    True Detective

    This anthology investagative drama series from HBO is the a great choice to dive into after finishing The Sinner if you're craving something in a similar vein.

    Police investigations unearth the personal and professional secrets of those involved.
    26 votes
    More True DetectiveRight Arrow
  • The Killing
    Photo: The Killing / AMC
    6
    25 VOTES

    The Killing

    This series is the perfect choice if you want to continue down your rabbit hole of investigative crime dramas after finishing The Sinner.

    The Killing, a riveting crime drama series, delves into the murky depths of complex murder investigations led by tenacious homicide detectives Sarah Linden (Mireille Enos) and Stephen Holder (Joel Kinnaman). Set against the backdrop of Seattle's gloomy skies, the show masterfully unravels each case with a meticulous attention to detail, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats. While receiving critical acclaim for its gripping narrative and stellar performances, The Killing has also been honored with several award nominations, including Primetime Emmy nods for Enos and Michelle Forbes, who plays the anguished mother of a murdered teenager. As the storylines unfold, the show skillfully examines the personal struggles of the characters, creating an intricate tapestry of suspense, emotion, and human connection.
    25 votes
    More The KillingRight Arrow
  • Fargo
    Photo: Fargo
    7
    16 VOTES

    Fargo

    Venturing into the frosty landscape of Minnesota, this darkly humorous crime drama weaves a complex web of deception and violence. With each season presenting a self-contained narrative inspired by the Coen Brothers' original film, viewers are immersed in the entangled lives of its multidimensional characters. Among them, Lorne Malvo (Billy Bob Thornton) embodies pure chaos, leaving a trail of destruction in his wake. The series has garnered critical acclaim for its exceptional storytelling and stellar performances, resulting in numerous award nominations, including Emmys and Golden Globes. Fargo's distinct blend of wit, suspense, and intricate plotlines ensures a memorable viewing experience without compromising on substance.
    16 votes
    More FargoRight Arrow
  • The Fall
    Photo: BBC Two
    8
    19 VOTES

    The Fall

    Fans of The Sinner will become obsessed with the outstanding performances given by Gillian Anderson and Jamie Dornan in this twisted British crime drama.

    A Detective Superintendent from England investigates a politically sensitive murder in Belfast.
    19 votes
    More The FallRight Arrow
  • Mindhunter
    Photo: Mindhunter / Netflix
    9
    47 VOTES

    Mindhunter

    Fans of The Sinner will love this period crime drama that explores the behavioral science behind the minds of imprisoned serial killers.

    A meticulously crafted crime drama, Mindhunter delves into the chilling world of criminal psychology and the birth of modern serial killer profiling. Boasting two seasons garnished with rave reviews, this gripping series presents an unnerving yet fascinating exploration of the darkest recesses of the human mind. Protagonists Holden Ford (Jonathan Groff) and Bill Tench (Holt McCallany), FBI agents in the Behavioral Science Unit, engage in intense interviews with notorious real-life murderers to understand their motivations and develop techniques to catch future criminals. The show's masterful storytelling, bolstered by its authentic period setting, has earned it widespread critical acclaim and a dedicated fan base.
    47 votes
    More MindhunterRight Arrow
  • You
    Photo: You
    10
    14 VOTES

    You

    A dangerously charming man falls in love with women and inserts himself into their lives.
    14 votes
    More YouRight Arrow
  • Hannibal
    Photo: Hannibal
    11
    13 VOTES

    Hannibal

    Hannibal is a psychological thriller that delves into the complex relationship between FBI special investigator Will Graham (Hugh Dancy) and Dr. Hannibal Lecter (Mads Mikkelsen), a psychiatrist with a taste for the macabre. The show intricately weaves together elements of crime, horror, and drama, presenting viewers with a fresh perspective on Thomas Harris's renowned literary characters. Nominated for multiple awards, including a Saturn Award for Best Network Television Series, Hannibal has garnered critical acclaim for its exceptional storytelling, stunning visual aesthetics, and the chilling performances of its lead actors. As the story unfolds, the lines between hunter and prey blur, leaving audiences questioning who they can truly trust.
    13 votes
  • Ozark
    Photo: Ozark / Netflix
    12
    8 VOTES

    Ozark

    In the shadowy world of financial crime, Ozark weaves a gripping narrative that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. This critically acclaimed drama series, with multiple Emmy and Golden Globe nominations to its name, follows the perilous journey of Marty Byrde (Jason Bateman) as he navigates the treacherous waters of money laundering for a ruthless drug cartel. Alongside his resourceful wife Wendy (Laura Linney), the couple encounters an array of complex characters and dangerous situations in the seemingly tranquil lakeside town. With its masterful storytelling and captivating performances, Ozark offers a thrilling exploration of morality, family dynamics, and the consequences of one's actions.
    8 votes
    More OzarkRight Arrow
  • American Crime Story
    Photo: American Crime Story
    13
    8 VOTES

    American Crime Story

    This anthology series from FX explores different crimes and the situations surrounding them each season and is the perfect guilty pleasure for fans of The Sinner to enjoy if they want a little melodrama mixed in with their normal dose of murder mystery. 

    A dramatization of true events.
    8 votes
    More American Crime StoryRight Arrow
  • Sharp Objects
    Photo: Sharp Objects
    14
    11 VOTES

    Sharp Objects

    This HBO drama series follows a reporter as she returns to her rural hometown to investigate the deaths of two young women shortly after leaving treatment for self-harm. Check out other shows like Sharp Objects.

    A reporter returns to her hometown to cover the murders of two preteen girls.
    11 votes
    More Sharp ObjectsRight Arrow
  • Dexter
    Photo: Showtime
    15
    7 VOTES

    Dexter

    A forensics analyst moonlights as a serial killer.
    7 votes
  • Prodigal Son
    Photo: Fox
    16
    6 VOTES

    Prodigal Son

    This drama series following a former FBI profiler and son of a serial killer is the perfect dark drama to soak up after finishing The Sinner.

    Prodigal Son is a psychological thriller that delves into the twisted relationship between a criminal psychologist, Malcolm Bright (Tom Payne), and his notorious serial killer father, Dr. Martin Whitly (Michael Sheen). With a compelling storyline, this gripping series explores the complexities of family dynamics while maintaining an air of suspense throughout. The show has garnered critical acclaim for its talented ensemble cast, including standout performances by Bellamy Young and Lou Diamond Phillips. Nominated for several awards, Prodigal Son consistently keeps viewers on the edge of their seats as it masterfully navigates the murky waters of morality and the haunting legacy of a murderous past.
    6 votes
    More Prodigal SonRight Arrow
  • The Girl on the Train
    Photo: Universal Pictures
    17
    10 VOTES

    The Girl on the Train

    Commuter Rachel Watson (Emily Blunt) catches daily glimpses of a seemingly perfect couple, Scott and Megan, from the window of her train. One day, Watson witnesses something shocking unfold in the backyard of the strangers' home. Rachel tells the authorities what she thinks she saw after learning that Megan is now missing and feared dead. Unable to trust her own memory, the troubled woman begins her own investigation, while police suspect that Rachel may have crossed a dangerous line.
    10 votes
    More The Girl on the TrainRight Arrow
  • Mr. Robot
    Photo: Mr. Robot
    18
    10 VOTES

    Mr. Robot

    Diving into the complex world of cyber-security, the critically acclaimed drama series unravels the gripping tale of a young programmer, Elliot Alderson (Rami Malek), who moonlights as a vigilante hacker. With a masterful blend of psychological thrills and tech intrigue, the show has garnered numerous accolades, including a Golden Globe for Best Television Series - Drama. As viewers navigate through the labyrinth of Elliot's fractured mind, they are introduced to an enigmatic group of hacktivists, led by the mysterious Mr. Robot (Christian Slater). Tackling timely themes such as corporate greed and societal disillusionment, Mr. Robot offers a thought-provoking exploration of power and control in the digital age.
    10 votes
    More Mr. RobotRight Arrow
  • Motherless Brooklyn
    Photo: Motherless Brooklyn / Warner Bros. Pictures
    19
    5 VOTES

    Motherless Brooklyn

    This period neo-noir film by starring and directed by Edward Norton is a great selection for fans of The Sinner that want just little more investigative drama for a rainy night in.

    Motherless Brooklyn is a 2019 crime drama film directed by Edward Norton, based on the 1999 novel of the same name by Jonathan Lethem. A private investigator (Edward Norton) with Tourette syndrome works to solve the mystery of his mentor's (Bruce Willis) murder in 1950s New York.
    5 votes
  • Dead to Me
    Photo: Dead to Me / Netflix
    20
    5 VOTES

    Dead to Me

    In a tale of friendship and dark secrets, Dead to Me delivers a compelling narrative that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. This critically acclaimed dark comedy series has garnered multiple award nominations, including an Emmy nod for its lead actress Christina Applegate. The plot revolves around the unlikely bond formed between two grieving women, Jen (Applegate) and Judy (Linda Cardellini), as they navigate through loss, deception, and the pursuit of justice. With each episode unveiling new twists, Dead to Me expertly weaves humor and heartbreak, creating a unique viewing experience that resonates with audiences.
    5 votes
    More Dead to MeRight Arrow
  • The Night Manager
    Photo: BBC One
    21
    5 VOTES

    The Night Manager

    Former British soldier Jonathan Pine works to infiltrate the inner circle of an arms dealer.
    5 votes
    More The Night ManagerRight Arrow
  • Hunters
    Photo: Hunters / Amazon Video
    22
    7 VOTES

    Hunters

    This Amazon series about a ragtag group of Nazi hunters is the perfect series choice if you're looking for a series to meet the same bar that The Sinner set.

    A gripping thriller series, Hunters delves into the world of Nazi hunters in 1970s New York City. The show's ensemble cast, led by Al Pacino as Meyer Offerman, takes viewers on a suspenseful journey as they uncover a clandestine organization of war criminals planning to establish a Fourth Reich in America. With its unique blend of historical drama and dark humor, the series has garnered critical acclaim, earning multiple award nominations for its talented cast members and exceptional storytelling. Hunters masterfully balances the intensity of its subject matter with moments of levity that make for an engaging and thought-provoking viewing experience.
    7 votes
    More HuntersRight Arrow
  • When They See Us
    Photo: Netflix
    23
    7 VOTES

    When They See Us

    This Netflix drama series exploring the false accusations five young men faced is a great choice if you love diving deep into The Sinner.. 

    When They See Us, a compelling four-part miniseries, delves into the harrowing true story of five teenagers from Harlem Antron McCray, Kevin Richardson, Yusef Salaam, Raymond Santana, and Korey Wise, who were falsely accused and convicted of a brutal crime in Central Park. Directed by the visionary Ava DuVernay, this powerful drama showcases outstanding performances from its ensemble cast, including Jharrel Jerome (Korey Wise), whose portrayal earned him a well-deserved Emmy Award. The series not only sheds light on the injustices faced by the Central Park Five, but also serves as a poignant reminder of the flaws within the criminal justice system.
    7 votes
    More When They See UsRight Arrow
  • Gone Baby Gone
    Photo: Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
    24
    5 VOTES

    Gone Baby Gone

    Fans of The Sinner will love this neo-noir drama following a pair of Boston detectives that are on the case to solve the abduction of a young girl.

    In the heart of Boston's gritty underbelly, private detectives Patrick Kenzie (Casey Affleck) and Angie Gennaro (Michelle Monaghan) are thrown into a morally complex world. They're hired to find a missing four-year-old girl, Amanda McCready. Directed by Ben Affleck, Gone Baby Gone is a gripping drama that explores the line between right and wrong. As the pair dig deeper into the case, they uncover a web of corruption and deceit within their own neighborhood. The film has earned accolades for its thought-provoking narrative and stellar performances. It's a tale of lost innocence, tough choices, and unexpected consequences.
    5 votes
    More Gone Baby GoneRight Arrow
  • The Night Of
    Photo: The Night Of / HBO
    25
    4 VOTES

    The Night Of

    Investigating a New York murder case.
    4 votes
    More The Night OfRight Arrow
  • 13 Reasons Why
    Photo: 13 Reasons Why
    26
    6 VOTES

    13 Reasons Why

    Exploring the complex tapestry of adolescence, 13 Reasons Why delves into the emotional turmoil experienced by high school students. With a gripping narrative that unravels through a series of audiotapes, the show follows Clay Jensen (Dylan Minnette) as he uncovers the reasons behind Hannah Baker's (Katherine Langford) tragic decision. Tackling sensitive subjects such as bullying, mental health, and sexual assault, the drama series has sparked necessary conversations among its viewers. Garnering critical acclaim as well as controversy, 13 Reasons Why pushed boundaries, providing a thought-provoking lens through which to view the challenges faced by today's youth.
    6 votes
    More 13 Reasons WhyRight Arrow
  • American Crime
    Photo: ABC
    27
    2 VOTES

    American Crime

    American Crime, which premiered on March 5, 2015, is a critically acclaimed anthology series that explores different criminal cases and their socio-political implications each season. The show investigates the themes of race, class, and gender politics in America. Notable actors include Felicity Huffman and Regina King, the latter of whom won two Emmy Awards for her performances across the series. With its gritty realism and complex characters, American Crime offers a thought-provoking examination of the American justice system and societal prejudices.
    2 votes
  • Penny Dreadful: City of Angels
    Photo: Penny Dreadful: City of Angels
    28
    2 VOTES

    Penny Dreadful: City of Angels

    Set against the vibrant and tumultuous backdrop of 1938 Los Angeles, this mesmerizing series explores a time rife with racial and political tensions. Penny Dreadful: City of Angels delves into the supernatural realm, seamlessly weaving together elements of crime, drama, and horror. The talented ensemble cast, including Detective Tiago Vega (Daniel Zovatto) and his enigmatic partner Lewis Michener (Nathan Lane), navigates the city's dark underbelly while confronting age-old Mexican folklore. Nominated for an impressive array of awards, this gripping show masterfully captures the essence of its era, offering viewers an enthralling journey through a world where danger and mysticism intertwine.
    2 votes
    More Penny Dreadful: City of AngelsRight Arrow
  • Waco
    Photo: Paramount Network
    29
    2 VOTES

    Waco

    A stand-off with a religious community.
    2 votes
    More WacoRight Arrow
  • Big Little Lies
    Photo: Big Little Lies
    30
    2 VOTES

    Big Little Lies

    The seemingly perfect lives of three mothers of first-graders begin to unravel, leading to murder.
    2 votes
    More Big Little LiesRight Arrow