Asked my wife the question and we both agree that Dylan McKay was the best looking guy. To me he’s truly iconic. My son is named Dylan too
Women for me it’s Valerie Malone ( Tiffany Amber thiessen) followed by Brenda Walsh
My wife votes for Summer
Overall cast for looks was the O.C.
I think OTH had some really pretty people too.
What are y’all’s thoughts on this?
Sort by:
New
Open comment sort options
Best
Top
New
Controversial
Old
Q&A
GOSSIP GIRL WINS. 🤣
Sophia Bush is the most beautiful woman compared to the shows you listed.
I don't find many of the men attractive, tbh, but if you put Smallville as a choice like another person suggested, then definitely Tom Welling wins by a large gap. He is the most handsome ever.
lol Chad Michael Murray ain’t too bad! Just can’t stand his “SQUINCHING” look 🤣 it reminds me of blue steel from Zoolander ☠️
Lmaoooooooo that is exactly why I don’t find him attractive at all 🤣
sophia bush is hands down the most beautiful woman i’ve ever seen in my life, cmon! & chad micheal murray is the epitome of 2000s sexy, and i’m not even into blonde white men whatsoever. oth definitely had the best looks.
I'd vote Sophia from OTH and Ben from the OC personally
One Tree Hill has the most attractive male and female cast because both leading men are very attractive and all the women are as well (Bethany Joy being the least attractive imo).
Mischa Barton whenever I look back at the OC is just stunning, and Adam Brody was pretty hot, but I never cared for Ben McKenzie and don’t find Rachel Bilson particularly pretty.
90210 I just never cared that much for Luke Perry but thought Jason Priestley was gorgeous (sadly very short), and while Shannen and Jennie had their moments, I don’t think they were prettier than the OTH ladies. Obviously Tiffani was beautiful, though I absolutely hated the haircut when she first joined the show. BAG actually was very good-looking, but he got some terrible styling throughout the show. The other two women I don’t think are that attractive.
I’ll take Rachel Bilson over Mischa Barton personally. Ben Mackenzie was not attractive but as far as male cast, I’d have to go with OTH. Altho Nate isn’t the best looking guy either.
Rachel Bilson and Mischa Barton are both pretty in their own ways….not even comparable it doesn’t have to be a competition. I’m guessing anyone who doesn’t find her attractive are not into hot brunettes lol!
I’d consider Mischa a blonde more than a “brunette” but definitely wouldn’t say it’s a competition.
I just personally don’t find Mischa attractive period and if I had to put her against Rachel Bilson…it’s Rachel Bilson all day altho I had a big crush on Peyton (Hilarie Burton) lol
No I’m talking about people who don’t find Rachel attractive….She’s the hot brunette lol.
Mischa Barton was extremely pretty on The OC and Tiffani Amber Theissen on 90210
Jason Priestly has the best looking face of all the males. But Ryan from OC had sexy masculine energy
100% agree with you!
Idk why I never found Mischa that attractive, too conventional, typical blonde model ehhh..
But Jason Preistly was very handsome in his prime! His jaw line is so well defined reminds me of James Dean!
Male: Jason Priestly
Female: Mischa Barton
Overall: The OC, by a mile
I think this is way too hard
Valerie Malone or Brooke Davis without a second thought
My brother’s middle name is Dylan after Dylan McKay lol. I’ve never seen 90210, but I have seen the other two shows. Both shows have amazing casts filled with very beautiful people. For personal taste I have to say Adam Brody is one of the best looking guys I have ever lied eyes on. He just takes the cake when it comes to looks in my opinion. My top 5 has to be Seth, Nathan, Lucas, Clay, and Ryan in that order.
Omg they're all gorgeous lol. I'm gonna say Jason Priestley and Tiffani Amber Theissen imo. One Tree Hill has the best looking overall cast though.
Agreed
It’s tough cause it’s kinda a battle of the brunettes. I think Brooke, Val, and Brenda are very pretty but I’m gonna give it to Val.
For guys I’d put Seth or Nathan but Nathan has it for me.
I will say tho the OC had a beautiful cast in Marissa, summer, Seth and even sandy for the girlies who like them older. Oth had Dan who I thought was cute for older too.
I think overall it’s kinda tied for entire casts
Damn, this is hard.
Best Cast Overall: Beverly Hills, 90210
Best Cast, Acting-Wise: One Tree Hill
Best Cast to Look the Ages Even When They Weren’t: The O.C.
Best Cast to Play a Believable Group of Friends: The O.C.
Best-Looking Male: Luke Perry tied with Jason Priestley, closely followed by Adam Brody, Ben Mackenzie, and Chad Michael Murray. And Brian Austin Green was a smokeshow in later seasons of BH.
Best-Looking Female: BH had Tiffani Thiessen and Shannen Doherty, which is just unfair to any of the other casts. BUT The O.C. did have Amanda Righetti (fun fact: she worked with Shannen in the short-lived North Shore [which also had Jason Momoa]) and One Tree Hill had Danneel Harris-Ackles, so…
For the OC: Alex. Theresa, Summer and Anna are in the conversation. Alex was jump off the screen 🔥.
Overall Cast: The OC
Best Male: Chad Michael Murray Best Female: Sophia Bush
Both have aged incredibly well too.
You are forgetting Smallville 💯
If Smallville is a choice then Tom Welling slaps every other male lead ever. He's stunningly handsome.
OTH: Chad Micheal Murray
Overall: The OC
Male: Brian Greenberg.
Female: Sophia Bush.
OTH
OTH for overall best looking cast. Sophia may be my all time celebrity crush.
Sophia Bush is one of the most beautiful humans alive, so her.
Overall: The OC Male:Ryan Atwood Female: Marissa Cooper
Cast; The OC male: Dylan McKay or Ryan Female: Marissa
Over all: One Tree Hill
Male: Chris Carmack
Female: Sophia Bush
Overall cast: The OC.
Male: Seth Cohen
Female: Peyton from One Tree Hill
I want a Seth and Peyton spinoff
I wholeheartedly agree with you on Peyton
Hilarie Burton is a natural stunner.
Obviously tons of beautiful people, I'm just not sure how I could possibly say anyone is more beautiful than the ethereal Mischa Barton.
I've never seen the other shows but for me The O.C.'s most attractive guys I'd say Ben and Adam and girls would be Mischa and Kelly. I also think Cam and Chris are very good looking, just not my type physically.