The Best Oakland Athletics of All Time

Ranker Baseball
Updated May 2, 2024 51.6K views 44 items
Ranked By
19.1K votes
1.9K voters
10 reranks
Voting Rules
Please only rank the players based on their time with the A's.

This is a list of the greatest Oakland Athletics ever. Founded in Philadelphia in 1901, the team now known as the Oakland Athletics (or Oakland A's) were one of the eight original American League franchises. The team's early years were marked by contending squads and the Athletics won the World Series five times (1910, 1911, 1913, 1929, 1930) during its tenure in the City of Brotherly Love. In 1955, the team left Philadelphia for Kansas City, where the team saw little success. Upon moving to Oakland ahead of the 1968 season, the A's had a resurgence and the team had a strong run of success through the mid 1970s capturing three straight World Series titles from 1972 through 1974.

The Oakland Athletics of the mid-70s featured some of the best players in A's history. Reggie Jackson, who earned the name "Mr. October" for his timely hitting during the playoffs, is one of the greatest players not only in Athletics history, but is one of the greatest players of all time. Jackson was a key cog in those championship teams' engine. He won the AL MVP award in 1973 along with the World Series MVP during the same season. Other key players from those teams included Catfish Hunter, Vida Blue and Rollie Fingers.

While the Bash Brothers (Jose Canseco and Mark McGwire were a big attraction in the late '80s, the Moneyball A's of the early 2000s featured some of the greatest players in team history. Behind the leadership of General Manager Billy Beane, the team featured one of the best pitching trios in team history (Tim Hudson, Barry Zito and Mark Mulder), powerhitting sluggers (Jason Giambi, Miguel Tejada) and one of the most underrated players in the game (Eric Chavez). These A's became pop culture phenomenons when they were subject of the 2011 film Moneyball starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill.

This is a list of the greatest Oakland A's of All Time. If you see someone who should be on this list, feel free to add him. Vote and rerank this list as you deem fit.
  • Rickey Henderson
    1
    1,149 votes

    Arguably the greatest leadoff hitter and baserunner in MLB history, Rickey Henderson's name became synonymous with the Oakland Athletics during his Hall of Fame career. With a keen eye for balls and strikes, uncanny ability to get on base, and unmatched speed that left opposing pitchers and catchers constantly on edge, Henderson was a game-changer in every sense of the word. Though he played for numerous teams throughout his illustrious career, it was with the A's that Henderson would cement his legacy, representing the epitome of the franchise during their most dominant years.

  • Reggie Jackson
    2
    924 votes

    Mr. October himself, Reggie Jackson left an indelible mark on the Athletics organization during his time in Oakland. A prodigious home run hitter, Jackson was instrumental in the A's capturing five consecutive division titles and three consecutive World Series championships in the early 1970s. Though he went on to find success with other organizations as well, Reggie's impact on the game and his iconic status in the annals of Oakland Athletics history remain undeniable.

  • Rollie Fingers
    3
    738 votes

    With his signature handlebar mustache and unflappable demeanor on the mound, Rollie Fingers epitomized the role of the modern-day closer during his tenure with the Athletics. Routinely entering the game in high-pressure situations, Fingers consistently delivered, using his vast array of pitches to baffle opposing batters and secure victories for his team. As a central figure in the A's three consecutive championships in the '70s, Fingers' contributions to the organization and the evolution of the closer role in baseball are immeasurable.

  • Catfish Hunter
    4
    720 votes
    Dec. at 53 (1946-1999)

    Combining a fierce competitive spirit with tremendous pitching skill, Catfish Hunter was a true ace on the mound for the Athletics during their championship years in the early '70s. With a penchant for fooling hitters with his devastating repertoire of pitches, Hunter was instrumental in securing key wins and establishing a winning culture within the organization. As one of the premier pitchers of his era, Catfish's contributions to the Athletics' success and his impact on the game at large can never be overstated.

  • Dennis Eckersley
    5
    811 votes

    One of the most feared and respected relief pitchers of all time, Dennis Eckersley's dominance in the late innings was a sight to behold. Known for his pinpoint control and fiery demeanor on the mound, "Eck" racked up an astonishing number of saves during his time with the A's while contributing greatly to the team's overall success. A Hall of Famer and key figure in Oakland's 1989 World Series title, Eckersley solidified his place among the best to ever don an Athletics uniform.

  • Vida Blue
    6
    625 votes
    Dec. at 73 (1949-2023)

    An electrifying presence on the mound, Vida Blue dazzled opposing hitters with his blazing fastball and knee-buckling curveball during his time in Oakland. A vital member of the A's pitching staff during their historic championship run in the early '70s, Blue was often called upon to shut down the opposition's best hitters in the most critical moments. The combination of his immense talent and unwavering self-assurance made Blue a standout performer and an unforgettable figure in the rich history of the Oakland Athletics.

  • Dave Stewart
    7
    575 votes

    Equipped with a menacing stare and an arsenal of pitches that left hitters baffled, Dave Stewart anchored the A's starting rotation throughout their late-'80s and early-'90s successes. Stepping up in the biggest moments, Stewart seemed to elevate his game when the stakes were highest, making him an invaluable asset to the organization. A consummate competitor and a beloved figure among fans, Stewart remains synonymous with the golden age of Oakland Athletics baseball.

  • Mark McGwire
    8
    758 votes

    A towering figure at the plate, Mark McGwire's prodigious power and ability to launch tape-measure home runs were unrivaled during his time in Oakland. As one half of the famed "Bash Brothers" duo alongside Jose Canseco, McGwire formed a heart of the order that struck fear into the hearts of opposing pitchers. Despite the controversy that would follow him later in his career, there's no denying the immense impact McGwire had on the Athletics organization during his tenure.

  • Joe Rudi
    9
    346 votes
    Age: 77

    Known for his clutch hitting and dazzling defensive ability in the outfield, Joe Rudi was a key contributor to the Athletics' championship runs in the early 1970s. With a knack for making timely plays both at the plate and on the field, Rudi's contributions may not always have garnered headlines, but they were instrumental in securing victories for the A's when it mattered most. A fan favorite and an integral part of the team's success, Rudi's place in Athletics history is well deserved.

  • Bert Campaneris
    10
    467 votes

    A versatile and talented player, Bert Campaneris was a linchpin of the A's early-'70s dynasty. With the ability to contribute in numerous ways -- whether it be with his bat, glove, or legs -- "Campy" had a profound impact on the A's, often utilizing his tremendous speed and instincts to wreak havoc on the basepaths. A six-time all-star, Campaneris was a force to be reckoned with in Oakland's formidable lineup and remains a beloved figure among Athletics faithful.

  • Sal Bando
    11
    440 votes
    Age: 80

    A consummate leader both on and off the field, Sal Bando was a key figure in the Athletics' success during their championship years in the early 1970s. As the team's captain and starting third baseman, Bando brought a level of consistency and grit to the lineup that would prove invaluable during those heated playoff battles. His steady presence at the hot corner and his ability to deliver in big moments made Bando an integral part of A's lore.

  • Dave Henderson
    12
    346 votes

    Dave "Hendu" Henderson was an electrifying presence in the Athletics' outfield during their late-'80s and early-'90s success. Known for his flair for the dramatic, Henderson had a penchant for coming through in clutch situations, delivering timely hits that proved key in A's victories. As one of the cornerstones of the Oakland dynasty during this era, his impact on the team's history should not be underestimated.

  • Carney Lansford
    13
    342 votes

    Carney Lansford's reputation as a fundamentally sound, hard-nosed player endeared him to fans and teammates alike during his tenure with the Athletics. As a reliable third baseman with a penchant for making great plays, Lansford provided stability for the A's infield while adding a tough, dependable bat to the lineup. His overall value to the organization throughout his time in Oakland is difficult to overstate, as he played a key role in multiple playoff runs and World Series appearances.

  • Bob Welch
    14
    293 votes
    Dec. at 57 (1956-2014)

    A key figure in the Athletics' starting rotation during their late-'80s and early-'90s success, Bob Welch consistently put forth strong performances on the mound that helped propel Oakland to multiple playoff appearances and a World Series title. Known for his tenacity and determination in high-pressure situations, Welch was a reliable option for the A's during a period of remarkable success for the franchise. His role in Oakland's winning culture and his contributions to the team's rich history should not be overlooked.

  • Jose Canseco
    15
    673 votes

    A colorful and larger-than-life character, Jose Canseco was half of the infamous "Bash Brothers" duo with Mark McGwire, forming a fearsome middle-of-the-order tandem for the Athletics in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Known for his monstrous home runs and intimidating presence at the plate, Canseco played a significant role in the team's period of dominance during that time. Though his career would ultimately be marred by controversy, there's no denying the impact he had on the Athletics and the game of baseball during his time in Oakland.

  • Eric Chavez
    16
    396 votes

    A standout third baseman during his tenure with the Athletics, Eric Chavez brought a rare combination of power at the plate and elite defensive skills to the hot corner in Oakland. A tireless worker and beloved figure among fans, Chavez was an integral part of the A's success throughout the 2000s, as his contributions helped to keep the team competitive in a difficult division. While injuries may have limited his career overall, his time in Oakland remains a testament to his immense talent and commitment to the game.

  • Gene Tenace
    17
    278 votes

    A clutch performer when it mattered most, Gene Tenace's contributions to the Athletics' championship teams of the early 1970s cannot be overstated. As an integral part of the lineup both offensively and defensively, Tenace provided a potent combination of power and patience at the plate while serving as a rock-solid defensive presence behind it. His role in some of the most memorable moments in Oakland's storied history ensures his place among the team's all-time greats.

  • Barry Zito
    18
    403 votes
    Age: 46

    With his unique pitching style and laid-back demeanor, left-hander Barry Zito quickly became a fan favorite during his time with the Athletics. A member of the vaunted "Big Three" starting pitchers alongside Tim Hudson and Mark Mulder, Zito excelled at keeping hitters off balance with his signature curveball and pinpoint control. Though he would ultimately find success with other organizations as well, Zito's impact on the A's during their run of success in the early 2000s stands as a testament to his exceptional talent.

  • Tim Hudson
    19
    379 votes
    Age: 48

    One of the premier starting pitchers of his era, Tim Hudson was a mainstay in the Athletics' rotation during the early 2000s. With his impressive arsenal of pitches and calm, collected demeanor on the mound, Hudson proved to be a dependable anchor for the A's pitching staff, consistently delivering quality starts and helping to guide the team through a highly competitive period in the AL West. His lasting impact on the organization can be seen in his numerous accolades and the high esteem in which he is still held by fans and teammates alike.

  • Dave Parker
    20
    233 votes

    A powerful presence at the plate, Dave Parker brought a potent combination of power and speed to the A's lineup during the late 1980s. With a smooth swing and an aggressive baserunning style, Parker was a key contributor to the Oakland dynasty that captured multiple pennants and a World Series title during his time with the team. Despite playing for several other organizations as well, Parker's impact on the Athletics' success is unquestionable.

  • Terry Steinbach
    21
    323 votes

    During his time with the Athletics, Terry Steinbach consistently showcased an impressive combination of skill and leadership behind the plate. A steady presence and guiding hand for Oakland's pitching staff throughout the late '80s and early '90s, Steinbach was not only a defensive stalwart but also managed to provide timely offense when needed most. His calm demeanor under pressure and genuine love for the game made him a beloved figure among teammates and fans alike.

  • Jason Giambi
    22
    418 votes

    One of the most feared sluggers of his era, Jason Giambi made a considerable impact on the Athletics organization during the late 1990s and early 2000s. With his ability to hit for both power and average, Giambi frequently struck fear into opposing pitchers as he stepped up to the plate. Though his career would ultimately be marred by controversy, few can deny the immense talent and production Giambi brought to the A's during his tenure.

  • Miguel Tejada
    23
    362 votes

    A dynamic and gifted shortstop, Miguel Tejada became a fan favorite in Oakland thanks to his electrifying style of play and love for the game. Known for his lightning-quick hands and strong arm in the field, as well as his potent bat in the lineup, Tejada was instrumental in helping to keep the Athletics competitive during the early 2000s. His flashy plays and undeniable passion for baseball left an indelible mark on the team's history.

  • Matt Chapman
    24
    160 votes

    A rising star in the league, Matt Chapman has quickly made a name for himself as one of the best third basemen in all of baseball. With his dazzling defensive skills and rapidly developing power at the plate, Chapman appears poised to become a fixture in the Athletics organization for years to come. As he continues to build upon an already impressive young career, there's little doubt that Chapman is well on his way to carving out his own unique spot in the annals of Oakland Athletics history.

  • Josh Donaldson
    25
    218 votes

    In just a few short years with the Athletics, Josh Donaldson emerged as one of the league's elite third basemen, thanks to his combination of extraordinary defensive skills and a potent bat. As a central figure in the A's resurgence in the early 2010s, Donaldson quickly became a fan favorite and a fearsome presence in the heart of the lineup. Though his time in Oakland was brief, the impact Donaldson made on the organization is impossible to ignore.

  • Mark Mulder
    26
    250 votes

    Mark Mulder, another member of the celebrated "Big Three" of the early 2000s, was instrumental in the Athletics' success during that era. With his tall frame, smooth delivery, and pinpoint control, Mulder consistently confounded hitters and racked up wins for the A's. As a key figure in one of the most dominant pitching trios in recent memory, Mulder's place in the annals of Oakland Athletics history is well secured.

  • Walt Weiss
    27
    220 votes
    Age: 60

    A slick-fielding shortstop with a flair for making highlight-reel defensive plays, Walt Weiss was an integral part of the Athletics' success during the late 1980s and early 1990s. Known for his range, soft hands, and strong arm, Weiss provided stability and a steady glove in a position crucial to the team's overall defense. A key member of the A's during a period of great success, Weiss' contributions to the storied Oakland history should not be overlooked.

  • Harold Baines
    28
    169 votes

    Despite playing a relatively brief tenure with the Athletics, Harold Baines’ time in Oakland deserves recognition for his steady offensive production and ability to come through in the clutch. An accomplished designated hitter, Baines provided a valuable veteran presence and a steady bat during his time with the A's. A seasoned professional, his contributions to the Oakland lineup proved invaluable in their pursuit of success.

  • Billy North
    29
    158 votes

    An incredibly fast and instinctive baserunner, Billy North left a lasting impression on the Athletics organization during his tenure in the 1970s. With a knack for getting on base and creating havoc once there, North utilized his speed and smarts on the base paths to help propel the A's to new heights. A key figure in Oakland's championship-winning years, North's impact on the game—and the team—remains an important part of Athletics history.

  • Dwayne Murphy
    30
    166 votes

    A stalwart in the Athletics' outfield during the late '70s and '80s, Dwayne Murphy consistently showcased both exceptional defensive skills and a productive bat. With his knack for making highlight-worthy catches and delivering timely hits, Murphy was a fan favorite and an integral part of the A's success throughout his time with the team. His strong work ethic and overall contributions to the organization secured his place in Oakland Athletics history.