The Most Successful Mad TV Cast Members

Ranker TV
Updated May 16, 2024 24.1K views 35 items
Ranked By
6.6K votes
1.0K voters
Voting Rules
Only actors who appeared on MADtv

List of the most successful Mad TV cast members, as ranked by fans and critics. From 1995-2009, the sketch comedy show Mad TV brought millions of people laughter on Fox and later on multiple networks while in syndication. The show introduced the world to a cast full of talented young comedians who created memorable characters and captivated live audiences with celebrity impressions. Mad TV ended up being a wackier version of Saturday Night Live and therefore produced quite a few famous, successful alumni. Former cast members of Mad TV have gone on to be popular comedians with large comedy tours,television and movies stars, and writers.

Although SNL lasted longer and was more critically acclaimed, Mad TV comedians managed to hold their own and find a place in the tough world of comedic acting. Actors like Alex Borstein, Bobby Lee, and Mo Collins work regularly in sitcoms, animation, and movies. Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele have found success in another sketch comedy show, while Mad TV alums like Taran Killam have been picked up by SNL.

Who are the most successful Mad TV cast members? This listfeatures the cast members who have found achievement in the entertainment business. 

Most divisive: Josh Meyers
Over 1.0K Ranker voters have come together to rank this list of The Most Successful Mad TV Cast Members
  • Jordan Peele
    1
    318 votes
    Key & Peele, Mad TV, Chocolate News

    Arguably one of the biggest breakout stars from MAD TV, Jordan Peele's undeniable talent shone through during his tenure on the sketch comedy show from 2003 to 2008. Of course, he's now best known as an Oscar-winning writer and director for his groundbreaking films, Get Out and Us, proving that his comedic genius easily translates to horror. Peele’s meteoric rise in Hollywood continues with his role as a creator, writer, and producer for The Twilight Zone revival, solidifying his status as a true creative tour de force.

  • Keegan-Michael Key
    2
    307 votes
    Key & Peele, Mad TV, Gary Unmarried

    Sharing the MAD TV spotlight with Jordan Peele from 2004 to 2009, Keegan-Michael Key quickly became a fan favorite with his razor-sharp wit and impeccable timing. The dynamic duo later went on to create the critically acclaimed and wildly successful sketch show Key & Peele. Nowadays, you'll find Key gracing both the big and small screens in a variety of roles, including voicing characters in popular animated films like Toy Story 4 and The Lion King, as well as starring in Apple TV+'s Schmigadoon!

  • Alex Borstein
    3
    305 votes
    Family Guy, Power Rangers, Getting On

    MAD TV audiences were first introduced to the hilarious Alex Borstein from 1997 to 2002, where she left an indelible mark with her memorable characters and sketches. Remarkably, Borstein is also the voice behind the iconic Lois Griffin on the long-running animated series Family Guy. Today, this versatile performer can be seen on the award-winning Amazon Prime series The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, where her portrayal of Susie Myerson has earned her two Primetime Emmy Awards.

  • Bobby Lee
    4
    311 votes
    Mad TV, Big Time Rush, Animal Practice

    From 2001 to 2009, Bobby Lee brought his unique brand of humor to the MAD TV stage, creating unforgettable characters and moments. Lee's natural talent for both physical comedy and character work ensured his place among the show's standout performers. Since leaving MAD TV, Lee has been a staple on various television shows and podcasts, notably appearing on Splitting Up Together and hosting the popular TigerBelly podcast.

  • Will Sasso
    5
    237 votes
    Mad TV, About a Boy, Bleep My Dad Says

    A stalwart of MAD TV from 1997 to 2002, Will Sasso had viewers in stitches with his spot-on impersonations and larger-than-life characters. His fearless commitment to physical comedy and versatility in playing various roles made him a standout. Following his time on MAD TV, Sasso continued to entertain audiences with appearances in popular shows like How I Met Your Mother and Modern Family, as well as films such as The Three Stooges.

  • Ike Barinholtz
    6
    193 votes
    The Mindy Project, Eastbound & Down, Mad TV

    Ike Barinholtz's undeniable charm and razor-sharp wit were on full display during his time on MAD TV from 2002 to 2007. From memorable impressions to uproarious original characters, Barinholtz brought his A-game to every sketch. Today, he's a highly sought-after actor and writer, with roles in hit movies like Neighbors and Blockers, as well as TV shows like The Mindy Project and Superstore.

  • Nicole Sullivan
    7
    227 votes
    The King of Queens, Kim Possible, The Penguins of Madagascar

    The vivacious Nicole Sullivan was a powerhouse on MAD TV from its inception in 1995 until 2001, showcasing her wide range of comedic talents. Her exceptional character work and bold humor made her a fan favorite during those early years. Post-MAD TV, Sullivan has enjoyed a successful career in voice acting, with signature roles in animated series like The Penguins of Madagascar and Rita Rocks, while also appearing on popular sitcoms like Black-ish and Disjointed.

  • Michael McDonald
    8
    246 votes
    Scrubs, Cougar Town, 7th Heaven

    As one of the longest-serving cast members in MAD TV history (1998-2008), Michael McDonald's comedic prowess is legendary. Known for his iconic creation of the infamous character Stuart, McDonald has since continued to make audiences laugh with appearances on ScrubsThe Ellen DeGeneres Show, and a recurring role on Brooklyn Nine-Nine.

  • Simon Helberg
    9
    163 votes
    The Big Bang Theory, Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog, Kung Fu Panda: Legends of Awesomeness

    Before he was known as the lovable Howard Wolowitz on The Big Bang Theory, Simon Helberg showcased his comedic chops as a MAD TV cast member from 2002 to 2003. Even in his short tenure on the show, Helberg's talent was evident. Today, his flourishing acting career includes critical acclaim for his standout performance in the film Florence Foster Jenkins opposite Meryl Streep.

  • Taran Killam
    10
    164 votes
    Saturday Night Live, The Jersey, Saturday Night Live Weekend Update Thursday

    Taran Killam's time on MAD TV from 2001 to 2002 served as a launching pad for his comedy career, allowing him to hone his skills and establish himself as an up-and-coming performer. After MAD TV, Killam continued his sketch comedy success with a six-year stint on Saturday Night Live. Recently, viewers have enjoyed his memorable roles on Single Parents, Archer, and in the Broadway production of Hamilton.

  • Mo Collins
    11
    176 votes
    Mad TV, Life's a Bitch

    One of the most versatile comedians to grace the MAD TV stage, Mo Collins entertained audiences from 1998 to 2004 with her memorable characters and impressions. Collins's wit and charisma endeared her to fans, and she's continued to make her mark on the comedy world with roles in popular shows like Parks and RecreationArrested Development, and Fear the Walking Dead.

  • Frank Caliendo
    12
    162 votes
    Hot in Cleveland, Mad TV, Mike & Mike

    During his time on MAD TV from 2001 to 2006, Frank Caliendo wowed audiences with his astonishingly accurate impersonations and unique comedic style. Best known for his uncanny impressions of celebrities like John Madden and Al Pacino, Caliendo has since become a staple on television and radio, regularly appearing on ESPN and hosting his own podcast, The Frank Caliendo Cast.

  • Artie Lange
    13
    162 votes
    The Norm Show, Howard Stern on Demand, Game Over

    As a cast member on MAD TV from 1995 to 1997, Artie Lange brought his distinct sense of humor to the sketch comedy world. After leaving the show, Lange found success as a regular sidekick on The Howard Stern Show for nearly a decade and later co-hosted his own radio show, The Artie Lange Show. Today, Lange remains an influential figure in stand-up comedy and has authored multiple books about his life and career.

  • Orlando Jones
    14
    149 votes
    Sleepy Hollow, How to Live with Your Parents (for the Rest of Your Life), Father of the Pride

    Operating as a MAD TV cast member from 1995 to 1997, Orlando Jones showcased his multitude of comedic talents by captivating viewers with his quick wit and dynamic characters. Post-MAD TV, Jones has continued to find success with roles in popular films like Drumline and Evolution, as well as memorable TV appearances on Sleepy Hollow and American Gods.

  • Stephnie Weir
    15
    149 votes
    Mad TV, Big Day

    Stephnie Weir's exceptional talent was evident during her time on MAD TV from 2000 to 2006, where she created a slew of memorable characters and showcased her impeccable sense of timing. Since her days on the show, Weir has continued to captivate audiences with appearances on popular sitcoms such as The ComediansSuperstore, and Happy Together.

  • Debra Wilson
    16
    164 votes
    Mad TV, Celebrity Paranormal Project, The Mr. Potato Head Show

    As one of the original MAD TV cast members, Debra Wilson delighted fans with her exceptional character work and memorable impressions from 1995 to 2003. Since leaving the show, Wilson has built an impressive resume in television and voice acting, with roles in popular series like Avatar: The Last AirbenderFamily Guy, and American Dad!

  • Bryan Callen
    17
    142 votes
    Death Valley, Inside Schwartz, Fat Actress

    From 1995 to 1997, Bryan Callen made his mark on MAD TV with his memorable characters and high-energy performances. After leaving the show, Callen continued to charm audiences on both the big and small screens, appearing in hit shows like The GoldbergsKingdom, and the popular movie The Hangover. A multitalented entertainer, Callen also hosts the successful podcast, The Fighter & The Kid.

  • Andy Daly
    18
    123 votes
    Eastbound & Down, Mad TV, Review

    During his time on MAD TV from 2000 to 2002, Andy Daly showcased his brilliant comedic timing and knack for creating hilarious characters. Post-MAD TV, Daly's career took off with appearances on Reno 911!Eastbound & Down, and his own Comedy Central show, Review. More recently, he's been lending his talents to the animated series Big City Greens and Kipo and the Age of Wonderbeasts.

  • Aries Spears
    19
    154 votes
    The Proud Family, Mad TV, C Bear and Jamal

    Aries Spears brought his razor-sharp humor and uncanny impressions to MAD TV from 1997 to 2005, quickly becoming one of the most memorable cast members in the show's history. Since then, Spears has remained a force in the world of comedy, with appearances on The BoondocksBlack Dynamite, and continued success in stand-up comedy.

  • Anjelah Johnson
    20
    121 votes
    The Resurrection of Gavin Stone, The Book of Life, MADtv

    Anjelah Johnson's undeniable charisma and comedic timing were on full display during her tenure on MAD TV from 2007 to 2008. Perhaps best known for her iconic "Bon Qui Qui" character, Johnson has since continued to delight audiences with her successful stand-up comedy career, which includes multiple comedy specials and appearances on popular talk shows.

  • Arden Myrin
    21
    85 votes
    Working, On the Spot

    Arden Myrin graced the MAD TV stage from 2005 to 2009, quickly becoming a fan favorite thanks to her infectious energy and comedic skills. Since departing the show, Myrin has remained a prominent figure in comedy, with guest roles on popular shows like Inside Amy SchumerFresh Off the Boat, and Shameless. Additionally, she hosts the successful podcast, Will You Accept This Rose? which playfully analyzes episodes of The Bachelor and its spin-offs.

  • Josh Meyers
    22
    89 votes
    That '70s Show, The Awesomes

    As a cast member from 2002 to 2004, Josh Meyers brought his unique brand of humor to the MAD TV stage. Since leaving the show, Meyers has enjoyed a successful acting career, with recurring roles on popular series such as That '70s ShowThe Mindy Project, and Red Oaks.

  • David Herman
    23
    74 votes
    Futurama, King of the Hill, Bob's Burgers

    From 1995 to 1997, David Herman was an integral part of the MAD TV ensemble, showcasing his impressive range as both a character actor and impressionist. Post-MAD TV, Herman has had a flourishing career in voice acting, with notable roles in animated series like Futurama, Bob's Burgers, and King of the Hill.

  • Mary Scheer
    24
    60 votes
    iCarly, The Penguins of Madagascar, MXC

    MAD TV fans were treated to Mary Scheer's comedic talents from 1995 to 1998, where she created numerous unforgettable characters and moments. She has since maintained a steady presence in television and film, with appearances on popular series like The Ellen ShowiCarly, and lending her voice to the animated sitcom Bunsen Is a Beast.

  • Pablo Francisco
    25
    53 votes
    VH1 ILL-ustrated

    Pablo Francisco showcased his exceptional impersonation skills and comedic talent as a cast member on MAD TV from 1996 to 1997. Since leaving the show, Francisco has built a successful career in stand-up comedy, releasing multiple comedy specials and touring worldwide.

  • Nicole Randall Johnson
    26
    55 votes
    Significant Others

    Bringing her undeniable talent and range to MAD TV from 2005 to 2007, Nicole Randall Johnson created memorable characters and sketches. Johnson has continued her acting career with appearances on popular television shows such as Reno 911!, "Superstore," and Brooklyn Nine-Nine.

  • Pat Kilbane
    27
    48 votes

    During his time on MAD TV from 1997 to 2000, Pat Kilbane delivered consistently hilarious performances and spot-on impressions. Post-MAD TV, Kilbane has found continued success in television and film, with roles in Semi-ProEuroTrip, and appearances on Malcolm in the Middle and Seinfeld.

  • Matt Braunger
    28
    49 votes

    Matt Braunger brought his unique comedic style and memorable characters to MAD TV from 2008 to 2009. Since then, his career has continued to soar with appearances on popular television shows like Up All NightAgent Carter, and The New Girl, as well as numerous stand-up comedy specials.

  • Christina Moore
    29
    50 votes
    That '70s Show, Jessie, Mad TV

    From 2002 to 2003, Christina Moore charmed MAD TV audiences with her incredible range and quick-witted humor. After leaving the show, Moore has enjoyed a successful acting career with appearances on series such as That '70s ShowTwo and a Half Men, and 90210.

  • Gillian Vigman
    30
    43 votes
    The Defenders, Sons & Daughters

    Gillian Vigman's unmistakable comedic talent shone during her time on MAD TV from 2003 to 2005. Since departing from the show, Vigman has built an impressive acting resume with roles in popular movies such as The Hangover and Step Brothers, as well as appearances on New Girl and Suburgatory.