DISCUSSION
Love both but Amazing is one of the best tracks on the album
aaaand Beautiful Stranger should've been included on Music just like American Pie
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options
Best
Top
New
Controversial
Old
Q&A
](https://a.thumbs.redditmedia.com/sw8aKWzY5X-wWc5cVBMIq5_LV1W8eOpR7KZdAsVQ8K4.jpg)
Should’ve been a single rather than WIFLFAG
I don't agree but I definitely wish the Music era got more singles. It deserved it, pun intended.
Just popping in to make my usual comment when this album gets brought up:
Impressive Instant should have been a single.
It was rumored to be the next single after what it feels like for a girl I think the music video backlash killed off the era
I kind of agree, though for a different reason. First, while I like the video and love the mix, the video didn't showcase the actual song properly at all. The video and the mix work well together, but there should have been another video or version of it with the album version to match what was played on the radio. To cut out all the verses is weird; it's not selling the same song.
I prefer "Amazing" over "Beautiful Stranger". "Beautiful Stranger" worked for the Austin Powers movie, but it's a song that, as I get older, I just become less fond of. Both certainly could and should have been released as singles, regardless of how similar they sound to each other. I think "Amazing" would have had some great mixes as well compared to the few boring mixes "Beautiful Stranger" had.
So you think Beautiful Stranger AND Amazing should've been on Music? I don't agree with that, for the same reason why both were not singles: too similar. I do love that guitar solo in the middle of Amazing.
The rumor is that WB wanted Amazing for a single, but she wanted Impressive Instant. She was touring and cut Amazing from the set list so WB couldn’t film a video. In the end, no single was released.
Amazing is ... amazing! Fucking love that song
Hard disagree! I love beautiful stranger and was so disappointed it wasn't featured in the celebration tour