Did I step out of line? : r/AskDad Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/AskDad icon
r/AskDad icon
Go to AskDad
r/AskDad

There seems to be a significant problem where many young people are without a good older "Dad" figure in their lives with whom they can talk frankly about life. Feel free to ask about anything. Life, death, sex and taxes. We're a helpful community and only ask that you be respectful and keep your elbows off of the table when you're eating.


Members Online

Did I step out of line?

This past Sunday we celebrated my mom's birthday. There were a few guests who showed up. We had a few beers and shots. My uncle has high blood pressure and kidney problems. When the guys started pouring out shots for each other I told him that he shouldn't be drinking and I'd take his shots for him. Did I step out of line for saying so?

He was caught off guard and asked if I were talking to him. I confirmed it and he said I could. He still took little sips, but would hand me the shots.

Later, I handed them slices of cake and gave him one. I was hesitant about it because he has Hyperglycemia, but he ate it.

I'm a guy btw.

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options

Maybe just phrase it a bit better next time.

"Hey Uncle, Are you OK with these with your health? I'd be happy to take one for the team if you want me to take yours."

is probably a better way to say it. It doesn't make any assumptions, but still offers support if he wants it.

I mean, it sounds like you handled it just right.

He listened, he heard the love behind it, and listened to the love, not the 'rudeness' of your requests.

Never be ashamed of speaking out with love to tell people what they need to know. They may not heed you, and they may not even acknowledge your reasons ... but they will always hear the love.

But lay off the cake - that stuff will kill you!

Thanks

The dadbod insult lol

More replies
u/lazyFer avatar

You phrased that shit badly, like really badly. You're also not the health police. I guarantee you do unhealthy shit too but probably don't have someone standing over you making rude comments like you're a child.

It was unbelievably rude of you to state "You shouldn't have that, I'll have it for you". This is the type of comment where the message is lost in the delivery for the most part.

Learn to speak more gently and ask rather than tell.

A couple of notes:

  • It takes a lot more than a shot or two to fuck too much with high blood pressure (if he's taking medication to control it)

  • You don't go into the nature and severity of the kidney problems, but it's possible that a little alcohol won't make them worse (this is where a gentle question about it comes into play rather than laying down the law as you did). There's a rather large difference between "no longer able to process alcohol" and "it'll make me feel shitty for a day"...I know people that are severely lactose intolerant and yet still insist on getting a shamrock shake every year, they just accept the bad time to follow because they enjoy the shake so much.

  • People with hyperglycemia that aren't constantly in the hospital have generally learned what they can manage, it's usually best to let them manage their own shit.

That was poorly communicated too.

It's learned behavior. I'm unlearning and relearning.

More replies