Official subreddit for the horror franchise known as Five Nights at Freddy's (FNaF) || Official Discord Server: https://discord.gg/freddit
And no it not a theroy it fact why because Mike schdmit Is to different from what we know so far he has a sister named Abby he has a mom who way to young to be ms aftorn and her casting make absolutely no since for what ms aftorn would look like hell the unamed villain looks more like ms aftorn then Mike mom and also Abby her existence never made any since to fans who believe in the Micheal aftorn is Mike schdmit theroy why because he not I also last name his last name is schdmit not aftorn and he just to differennt from what we know who Micheal aftorn is I get alot of fans want to see Micheal aftorn in this movie but Micheal Schmidt isint Micheal aftorn and we don't even know if the aftorn family exists in this movie I know that going to make alot of fans who are excited for the movie mad at me but you can't get mad at me for not have unrealistic expectations for this movie we assumeing way to Much when we have barely any Information all I'm trying to say is Micheal aftorn isn't Mike schdmit and I notice alot of fans who believe in this theroy will use the excuse well It a au so It different from the games yhes it is and I agree with that but from what we know so far Micheal Schmidt just doesn't seem like he will be Micheal aftorn I know I have poor evidence for this theroy witch is fact but okay but the reason for that is that we have very little information and what we know so far Mike schdmit will not be Micheal aftorn
Mike's mom looking young doesn't really impact the chances of her being Mrs. Afton because we don't even know what her role in the film is as of now, for all we know they could be for flashbacks. Abby’s description does mention how she’s grown up without her parents.
As for Abby, this next part is complete speculation as we still don't have much to work off of currently. There hasn't been much official information released for the movie's plot beyond a few character descriptions and name for other characters. So what I'm about to say could very well be wrong just as much as it could easily be right, there's not much to point towards either at this time.
But a plausible explanation for Abby under the idea Movie Mike Schmidt = Michael Afton is that she's simply a version of Elizabeth who survived and had her identity changed at the same time as Mike's. It's not out of the realm of possibilities given Michael is mentioned to be dealing with regret from a previous incident and the previously mentioned detail of Abby not growing up with parents. Something happened and we might see that in the film, especially if William is involved.
As for if the Afton family exists in the movie universe regardless of if Mike Schmidt is one or not, I mean it's not out of the realms of possibility when William Afton does.
I feel saying it's a fact that Movie Mike Schmidt is not Michael Afton is incorrect, it's a theory just as the idea of the two being the same is. Neither is confirmed at this time and we'll likely receive the answer when the movie releases
Is Mike Schmidt being Michael Afton even confirmed to be true in the games?? I know that was a popular theory for a long time, and one that a few sorta just accepted as absolute truth, but I haven't really found anything confirming it anyway.
It's never directly said "Michael Afton is Mike Schmidt" but it's very heavily implied to be the case given the following:
Michael Afton is heavily implied to be the "Mike" that writes/draws in The Survival Logbook given the various references to Immortal and the Restless, the Exotic Butters from SL, and so on.
Said Mike draws Nightmare Fredbear under "draw your recent dreams" suggesting they are the FNaF 4 gameplay player.
FNaF 4's gameplay has the animatronics mirror their behavior from FNaF 1, Nightmare shares the same jumpscare as and reverse palette of Golden Freddy, and the Night 1 phone call from FNaF 1 can be heard in the background distorted. So this ties the player back to Mike Schmidt.
So while it's never outright said, it's very much the implication.
“Aftorn”
Dude, use a period.
He is literally 12 years old
So old enough to use a period.
Well.....
I actually have no comebacks so............................................................................................................................................................................................................... <-- Here you go.
Mike can just change his last name, as many children of murderers have done
Is English your first language? It's kind of a headache trying to read this; it reads the same way it would sound if you spoke to me without stopping to breathe.
It's a official Michael Afton and Mike Schmidt are not the same characters, Elizabeth isn't Abby Schmidt, Evan is not Garret either making the Schmidt family a parallel of the Aftons.