Which version is better? Symphonic metal or pop cover?

I only just discovered udio *very* recently and made a song for an Au/fan story I'm working on that has dark themes. So naturally I wrote a song to match the theme and tone of this story.

The problem is, I tried pop while waiting and it sounds pretty catchy, so I'm stuck trying to decide between the two. I like the Symphonic metal version as well but because I'm so new to this, I wanted to ask for some feedback on this matter.

Symphonic metal version:
https://www.udio.com/songs/gwe4QyRTCmvS7UogSWvY8m

Pop cover:
https://www.udio.com/songs/vCsXLQEU8D8NQhkkXW93i1