What are your thoughts on Journey Beyond Sodor? : r/thomasthetankengine Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/thomasthetankengine icon
r/thomasthetankengine icon
Go to thomasthetankengine
r/thomasthetankengine
A banner for the subreddit

A community run channel for fans of Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends! We talk about the TV Series, Railway Series, merchandise, and more!


Members Online

What are your thoughts on Journey Beyond Sodor?

Television Series
Open total votes
Best movie of the bunch!A seriously great ride!Ain't half bad, that's for sure.It's OK...Nope, not really a fan.It got way too many things wrong...
Closes
Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options

It was fine, could have been better, but it was "fine".

The main issue is that the locations don't really feel "Beyond" Sodor.

You could easily have made the steelworks and experimental engine yard located on Sodor itself and nothing would have changed.

Fourth best movie and extremely overhated. Yeah it has a few issues but what movie doesn't? JBS is a lot of fun regardless of them. Also Beresford wasn't pointless

If memory serves me it was ok, some good ideas bit some not so good ideas.

A good movie but I have issues with it. The bouncing is annoying and I hate the ending.

I think the bouncing definitely works for the musical numbers, but aside from that it can get a bit much. As for the ending, I think it was pretty good, but maybe delay the song to after Thomas and James return and get interrogated by Topham.

More replies