Ana Gasteyer on After Midnight on May 15 : r/LiveFromNewYork Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/LiveFromNewYork icon
r/LiveFromNewYork icon
Go to LiveFromNewYork
r/LiveFromNewYork
A banner for the subreddit

This place has it all!


Members Online

Ana Gasteyer on After Midnight on May 15

Cast News
Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options
u/usarasa avatar

I was a huge fan of the original. I was excited when I heard they were bringing it back. I watched it the first couple of weeks and I had to stop. I saw a sanitized, slower paced version of the show I loved. It’s like they cleaned it up for network. That show needs to be on cable (yeah I know there’s not much difference anymore but still) and it doesn’t have to be an hour. I don’t blame the host, Taylor Tomlinson is new to hosting AFAIK and I’m sure she’ll get her sea legs with enough reps. If it’s really overcome the early issues maybe I’ll give it another shot down the line.

u/TokenEntryWasBetter avatar

Nah it's fine.

More replies

+Micheala Watkins May 13

u/hopalongigor avatar

Good for her but the show is really bad. How are going to make a "talk show" into a game show? It's not what people want to see at 12:30 AM. I think the host got screwed. I wish her well.

I think it’s doing quite well. Personally it’s not always my cup of tea, but occasionally very funny (heavily depending on the panel guests of course).

u/hopalongigor avatar

Yeh, it's hit or miss but that format is so wrong for that time of night.

More replies
u/thecricketnerd avatar

I love the show. I also loved @midnight. There are far too many regular talk shows and they're stale. Why would I wanna hear some A-listers talk about pranks on set when I can see Chris Redd and Ana Gasteyer and some of my favorite comedians be silly?

u/hopalongigor avatar

I think it's 100% scripted. Some of the deliveries are kind of stale and lame. Very little improv going on.

u/thecricketnerd avatar

It's not scripted, they just get to do some of their answers ahead of the taping. There's plenty of banter depending on who's on the panel, the show's getting looser over time as well.

u/hopalongigor avatar

Sorry, the format kills me. Craig Ferguson changed the game and no one else has stepped up.

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
u/monsieurxander avatar

I've been enjoying it. Some rough episodes early on, but after a bit they found their footing.

u/hopalongigor avatar

After Craig Ferguson, I'm a bit spoiled now.

More replies
u/upvoter222 avatar

Here's a video of the show's host sort of addressing that criticism.

Based on watching the show and its earlier incarnation, I really don't see it as a talk show. It seems more like a series of comedy prompts.

u/hopalongigor avatar

I do appreciate her talent but even she says, she's really not involved in the making of the show other than the role she plays. She'd rather be doing stand up.

More replies
More replies