Dual leslie for clonewheel? - The Organ Forum
  • Welcome To The Organ Forum

    If this is your first visit
    • Most, but not all, content on this site can be viewed without being a member.
    • You must be a member to post here.
    • Registration is FREE. If you are asked for a payment, you have clicked on an ad.
    • Click this link for Registration instructions.
    • You must Register to become a member.
    • Be sure to check out the Help Page and FAQ for useful information on using the Forum.
  • Have You Forgotten Your Password or Username?

    If you're already a member and have forgotten your credentials, read this on how to recover them.

    How To Recover Your Username and Password

Forum Top Banner Ad

Collapse

Ebay Classic organs

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Dual leslie for clonewheel?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Dual leslie for clonewheel?

    Hello. I have been investigating the best way to connect my XK-5 to a 145 or 147. I'm leaning towards a Boss Organ tube pre pedal. The option is there to order two multi pin outputs. My question is, what are the advantages and challenges of a dual leslie setup? I assume there will be variance as to how they change speeds. Will there be phase issues? would it be a problem to use a 147 and a 145 simultaneously? I trying to gauge if this would be cool or more trouble than its worth. Its for home use only.

  • #2
    Two leslies are always better than one! Yes, of course, they will change speeds differently, they'll probably run at very slightly different speeds, and I always liked to set the treble horns on different steps on the pulleys anyway. Phase issues? The sounds will be out of phase due to the mechanics of what's going on (not out of phase as in +/- connections being reversed) but that's a good thing. The sounds and reflections will interact in a multiplicity of ways, changing every second. Imagine a string quartet for a moment. Now double the number of players and double again. There will be all sorts of phasing 'issues' but that's what makes the ensemble bigger. each time.

    More than two leslies? The tremolo effect will gradually start to be more diffuse. I think my max was 8, including some 145s, 147s, a 125 and some 760s (it was 50+ years ago and I wish I'd written it all down, taken photos and recorded it). Still sounded pretty cool and absolutely no problem in mixing leslie types. 145 + 147 would be just fine!

    Bottom line? If you've got the space and can afford it, then go for it and enjoy!
    It's not what you play. It's not how you play. It's the fact that you're playing that counts.

    New website now live - www.andrew-gilbert.com

    Current instruments: Roland Atelier AT900 Platinum Edition, Yamaha Genos, Yamaha PSR-S970, Kawai K1m
    Retired Organs: Lots! Kawai SR6 x 2, Hammond L122, T402, T500 x 2, X5. Conn Martinique and 652. Gulbransen 2102 Pacemaker. Kimball Temptation.
    Retired Leslies, 147, 145 x 2, 760 x 2, 710, 415 x 2.
    Retired synths: Korg 700, Roland SH1000, Jen Superstringer, Kawai S100F, Kawai S100P, Kawai K1

    Comment


    • #3
      I agree with Andy. although I have a an analog ancient B3, I found that dual Leslies (147 and 21H 2-speed mod) is a rich experience. A Hammond tech artfully set them up to run off one moon switch. Plus, if one goes down and needs work for some reason, there is redundancy. We learned in anatomy classes that dual Leslies is the only reason we have 2 ears, one on each side of our head. :cool:
      1955 B3, Leslie 21H and 147. Hammond A100 with weird Leslie 205. 1976 Rhodes. Wurlitzer 200A. Yamaha DX7/TX7. Korg M1. Yamaha C3 grand, 67 Tele blond neck, Les Paul Standard, PRS 24, Gibson classical electric, Breedlove acoustic electric, Strat, P Bass, Rogers drum kit, Roland TD 12 digital drums, Apollo quad, older blackfaced Fender Twin, other amps, mics and bits and pieces cluttering up the "studio."

      Comment


      • #4
        I found that dual Leslies (147 and 21H 2-speed mod) is a rich experience.
        That is what I have currently connected to my C3 with solid state relays in both which also gives me a stop function. Great sounding rig. I have a JR20 cabinet in need of a amp refurb which I may add for reverb.
        The bottom end of that 21H rattles the pictures on the wall.

        Jim

        Comment


        • Tonewheel
          Tonewheel commented
          Editing a comment
          Wow, Jim, how is that for coincidence? For me, the 147 bass reorganizes the china cabinet upstairs and rural neighbourhood dogs for miles around become incontinent. And that's with the rocker on soft. Well, maybe this is exaggerating a little...

      • #5
        I couldn't find this in the XK-5 manual but with the XK-3c the digital Leslie is still available on the left 1/4" output when the 11 pin Leslie connection is used. If the XK-5 works the same way you have the option of adding a 3rd Leslie. Just connect that output to an amp and pick (or create) the Digital Leslie that blends best with the others. You could also set the digital Leslie to PR-40 and have it sound like a Hammond Tone Cabinet. You would also still have the Un-Leslied right 1/4" output available. Let no output go unused.

        Edit: Never mind. I found a note in the manual (Pg. 15) that says the digital Leslie is disabled when the 11 pin connector is used. That's too bad, I use the 1/4" output as a PR-40 on my XK-3c. It sounds nice.

        Comment


        • andyg
          andyg commented
          Editing a comment
          Still worth checking. The manual might be saying that the digital sim is disabled only for the 11-pin socket. Only one way to find out.

      • #6
        Originally posted by andyg View Post
        Two leslies are always better than one! Yes, of course, they will change speeds differently, they'll probably run at very slightly different speeds, and I always liked to set the treble horns on different steps on the pulleys anyway. Phase issues? The sounds will be out of phase due to the mechanics of what's going on (not out of phase as in +/- connections being reversed) but that's a good thing. The sounds and reflections will interact in a multiplicity of ways, changing every second. Imagine a string quartet for a moment. Now double the number of players and double again. There will be all sorts of phasing 'issues' but that's what makes the ensemble bigger. each time.

        More than two leslies? The tremolo effect will gradually start to be more diffuse. I think my max was 8, including some 145s, 147s, a 125 and some 760s (it was 50+ years ago and I wish I'd written it all down, taken photos and recorded it). Still sounded pretty cool and absolutely no problem in mixing leslie types. 145 + 147 would be just fine!

        Bottom line? If you've got the space and can afford it, then go for it and enjoy!
        Thanks for this detailed and very helpful reply. I am new to all this, and trying to get the most authentic experience possible out of this clone wheel.

        Comment


        • #7
          Originally posted by JJMcS View Post
          I couldn't find this in the XK-5 manual but with the XK-3c the digital Leslie is still available on the left 1/4" output when the 11 pin Leslie connection is used. If the XK-5 works the same way you have the option of adding a 3rd Leslie. Just connect that output to an amp and pick (or create) the Digital Leslie that blends best with the others. You could also set the digital Leslie to PR-40 and have it sound like a Hammond Tone Cabinet. You would also still have the Un-Leslied right 1/4" output available. Let no output go unused.

          Edit: Never mind. I found a note in the manual (Pg. 15) that says the digital Leslie is disabled when the 11 pin connector is used. That's too bad, I use the 1/4" output as a PR-40 on my XK-3c. It sounds nice.
          I dont plan to use my 11 pin connector. Just 1/4 inch into the boss organ pre pedal, which will have two nine pin outputs for 147.But yes, I should still have another 1/4 output for the digital leslie sim. (if of course I understand this correctly).

          Comment


          • andyg
            andyg commented
            Editing a comment
            I hope you meant 6-pin sockets for the 147. 9 pins would be for the solid state leslies, like the 760. Mind you, unless you're planning to turn the 145/147s up to max and go for overdrive, the 760s sound darned good in a home setting.

        • #8
          Originally posted by wengr View Post

          I dont plan to use my 11 pin connector. Just 1/4 inch into the boss organ pre pedal, which will have two nine pin outputs for 147.But yes, I should still have another 1/4 output for the digital leslie sim. (if of course I understand this correctly).
          This adapter cable: https://hammondorganco.com/studio-12-cable may enable you to use the 11 pin connector into the pedal.

          Comment


          • #9
            Yes sorry, I'm going to order the pedal with dual six pin outputs.

            Comment


            • #10
              Boss Organ Pre Pedal? Can you add a link please?
              Hammond A-100
              Crumar Mojo XT
              Leslies 46 W, 51, 330, 2 x 760

              Comment


              • #11
                Originally posted by martin62 View Post
                Can you add a link please?
                google boss organ pedal
                Relatively new one man operation startup business in MA

                FWIW the complete text of the
                • "RETURN & REFUND POLICY


                  If you have any problems with any of our products, call us and we will work it out."
                Might be good to inquire if, or for for how long they accept returns just in case you change your mind for some yet unknown reason

                Comment

                Working...
                X