I need to be the superior movie picker : r/MovieSuggestions Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/MovieSuggestions icon
r/MovieSuggestions icon
Go to MovieSuggestions
r/MovieSuggestions
A banner for the subreddit

In the mood for a particular movie? Saw something interesting and want more? Have a favourite movie you want to recommend? Make those Movie Suggestions.


Members Online

I need to be the superior movie picker

REQUESTING

My girlfriend and I are currently partially long distance. Due to the distance, we try to spend our time bonding by doing things together, but virtually. One of the activities we partake in is watching movies together. We have this competition to see who picks the better movies

I’m looking for a movie that is everything she loves so I can blow her out of the water. She likes the following: time period movies that are not only accurate but have a decent plot. She loves color theory in movies and always seems to point it out when she notices. She also is a sucker for romance, but not afraid of a little action. The plot doesn’t necessarily have to be completely romantic as her favorite movie is sucker punch. She likes a little bit of the spook sometimes too!

From what I’ve gathered, here is a short list her favorites (in no particular order): sucker punch, last night in soho, atonement, crimson peak, kill bill, Jane air, pride and prejudice, Tim Burton Alice in wonderland, and zombieland.

Knowing her favorites and what she enjoys, what would you suggest? Your answer may help me become the best movie picker!

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options

Flesh and Bone

Innerspace

u/Mynock33 avatar

Warm Bodies

Big Trouble vin Little China

Simon Birch

Lucas

Who Framed Roger Rabbit

u/Intelligent_Luck120 avatar

Being John Malkovich

White men can’t jump

Hiroshima Mon amour

Before sunrise

u/ISurvivedCrowleyHigh avatar

Flesh And Blood (1985)

u/JCVD-88 avatar

Amadeus (1984)

u/VideoGuy1X avatar

Hope And Glory (1987)

Sisters Of War (2010)

The Colour Room (2021)

u/StinkyBrittches avatar

The Cook, The Thief, His Wife, and Her Lover, 1989

From Hell

The age of Innocence (1993)

The Importance of Being Earnest (2002) Period piece rom-com.

Lupin III: The Castle of Cagliostro (1979) Animated crime/action adventure. Incredible use of color.

Moulin Rouge (2001) Romance/musical. Great color, costumes, and sets.

  • Donnie Darko

  • The Darjeeling Limited

  • In The Mood for Love

Guns Akimbo

Natural Born Killers

Suspiria

House of 1000 Corpses

......Love the color palette in these films

Groundhog Day

The Fifth Element

Twelfth Night (From the wikipedia: "is a 1996 romantic comedy film adaptation of William Shakespeare's play, directed by Trevor Nunn and featuring an all-star cast. Set in the late 19th century"

If she likes that, there are other Shakespeare adaptations:

Kenneth Branagh's Much Ado About Nothing

Midsummer Night's Dream - either the 1936 black and white or the 1999 color version.

If you want to go really old school black and white there are a couple of great rom-coms from the 1930s

My Man Godfrey (my favorite, not to be confused with the 1950s version) and

It Happened One Night

Predator. The body mass alone…

Blade Runner 2049. A textbook of color theory.

Only Lovers Left Alive

Angel Heart

Shutter Island

u/Meyou000 avatar

Hero (2002)

Shadow (2018)

Curse of the Golden Flower (2006)

u/od0m15 avatar

DeliciousDélicieux (2021)

From Dusk Til Dawn.

u/Dry-Exchange2030 avatar

!. Farewell My Queen(French)

2. Anna Karenina (Keira Knightley version. Same director as Atonement)

3. Muriel's Wedding

4. Dr. Zhivago (Omar Sharif version)

5. The Prestige (This one sounds the most perfect for her)

6. Belfast

7. The Electrical Life of Louis Wain

Get back to us in a couple of months and let us know which films worked for you both. Happy viewing

I used Anna karenina as my choice tonight. SHE FELL IN FUCKING LOVE! I quite honestly really enjoyed this movie too and we’ve been discussing for about an hour so far. She has also purchased the book! Thank you so much!

u/Dry-Exchange2030 avatar

Oh I'm so glad you enjoyed it. I've heard the film veers a bit from the book but I loved how it's staged. Literally one of the most beautiful films I've ever seen. Amazing art direction and set design.

Hah I appreciate the stage pun. And I agree completely. Every scene in this movie was beautifully shot. My only qualm was not seeing alexeis reaction to Anna’s suicide but I think we already saw it when his horse died. Gosh this was such a good recommendation. I can’t thank you enough!

More replies
More replies
More replies

Moulin Rouge

Slumdog Millionaire

City of God

Belle (2013)

Brooklyn

Emma.

Far from the Madding Crowd (2015)

The Invitation (2022)

The Man from UNCLE

Atomic Blonde

Haywire

Shakespeare in Love

Lady Chatterly’s Lover (2022)

Bright Star

Elizabeth (1998)

Mansfield Park (1999)

Ravenous (1999).
It’s a fun mix of a few of the things you mentioned.

Noticed a trend of heroine leads who challenge gender stereotypes and exceed traditional expectations. Based on this, I'd recommend:

-Coraline

-La La Land

-Lady Bird

-The Menu

You sir hit the nail on the head!

More replies

Dangerous Liaisons

Edut: splng

[deleted]
[deleted]

Comment removed by moderator

u/AutoModerator avatar

Your comment was removed because we don't allow any YouTube, Dailymotion, Archive links (see explanation here). Note: Editing your removed comment won't approve it, you need to re-submit it without the URL. Make sure to read the Piracy rule (#4) before re-submitting.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

More replies

Great Expectations (1998)