What’s a band that’s only made one album but it’s a masterpiece? : r/musicsuggestions Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/musicsuggestions icon
r/musicsuggestions icon
Go to musicsuggestions
r/musicsuggestions

A place to ask for music suggestions and help others discover something new.


Members Online
[deleted]

What’s a band that’s only made one album but it’s a masterpiece?

My pick is Rupa - Disco Jazz

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options

Above by Mad Season

Myyy paiaaaiaaain is self choooseeennnn

More replies

Fuck I was gonna say that, but you took it. I had to say Mother Love Bone good one man that is like my fucking favorite album in the top five of all time.

I think it's worth elaborating for younger music fans. This album came out during the days of grunge and the band is a "supergroup" comprised of Mike McCready (of Pearl Jam), Layne Staley (of Alice in Chains), Barrett Martin (of Screaming Trees), and John Baker Saunders (of The Walkabouts).

Temple of the Dog is a similar supergroup that only released one self-titled album. The band consisted of Chris Cornell (of Soundgarden), Stone Gossard (of Pearl Jam), Jeff Ament (of Pearl Jam), and Matt Cameron (who would play with both Soundgarden & Pearl Jam), and.... Eddie Vedder (of Pearl Jam).... on backing vocals!

I think a lot or most people know about the latter project, but as I said, I understand that there are younger redditors around who might just be getting into some of this stuff retroactively, so there are some interesting details.

More replies
More replies

Blind Faith

u/Pretend_Berry_7196 avatar

Can’t believe I had to scroll this far down to find this.

That's because most of us who remember it well are getting old.

More replies
More replies
More replies

Jeff Buckley - Grace

Go to the top with this one

Absolutely ethereal

RIP Jeff

u/adiosmith avatar

The guitar tech for Jeff Buckley became an artist himself. Check out Ours, you can hear the influence.

More replies

HE ONLY HAS ONE ALBUM??

man i was really getting into his stuff

Yeah. He drowned while swimming before he finished his second album.

u/guitargoddess3 avatar

Creepy how his Dad who also died young, Tim Buckley, wrote Song to the Siren.. I know it’s supposed to be a metaphor for love but I can’t help but think how a watery death also relates to the lyrics.

why is it always the good ones. i swear

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
u/Curious-ficus-6510 avatar

I remember finding his CD in the University Library collection, listening to it on my Discman and being amazed by it. Some time later, he performed in Auckland and I thought about going, but I must have had something else on or been broke, so I thought maybe next time. Chose wrong that time, unlike when I made sure to catch Nirvana perform the one time they came to NZ.

u/hermajestythebean avatar

First album to ever make me cry. I would give anything to get him back.

Oh shit, never saw that album as a one and done, but I guess so. Wow! So good.

There have been some posthumous releases of unreleased tracks, but that's the only album he released in life.

If anybody in this thread loves Grace, but hasn't checked out Sketches For My Sweetheart The Drunk, it's well worth your time. Outstanding album, as rough as it is.

More replies
More replies
u/DeepestBeige avatar
Edited

The posthumous album, Sketches for my Sweetheart the Drunk, is great. They’re mostly unfinished songs, but some real gems in there nonetheless. “Vancouver” never fails to give me goosebumps

More replies

Give Up by The Postal Service

u/Reddit_Foxx avatar

They took their own advice to heart.

u/hermajestythebean avatar

underrated comment

More replies

And seeing them live with Death Cab this year was amazing!

I just saw the show in orlando. Was amazing. Jenny Lewis was incredible

More replies

Does Ben sing for both sets???

Yes, and he even changes outfits between sets (at least he did when I saw them). Dave Depper also played guitar for both.

More replies
More replies

That album is so solid and the two artists never recorded live together! It was all done through, ahem, the postal service.

More replies

Really only one album?

I didn’t believe it either and just looked it up and sure enough they only have one album. Give up in 2003. Just a few singles after that.

They basically launched 00’s eta indie and that garden state album was really good. I’m shocked.

Estimated time of arrival indie?

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
u/jb0nez95 avatar

Yeah but Death Cab For Cutie was the singer's new band and they've released loads since then.

u/MILK_DUD_NIPPLES avatar

Death Cab was around first. The Postal Service was basically a side project.

More replies
More replies
More replies

Derek and the Dominoes

LAAAAAAAYYLAAAA

More replies

Fav band of all time.

I've always counted their 1973 In Concert album as their best. The studio album production sounds a bit thin compared with their best live shows.

But I've always been partial to concert albums from that era. If I had to pick only one album from some favorite bands, it'd be The Doors Absolutely Live, Allman Brothers Fillmore East, Grateful Dead Europe '72, Hendrix Band of Gypsys, Stones Ya-Ya's, and In Concert 1973 for Clapton's best work.

More replies

Came here for this

More replies

Operation ivy

u/darthwader1981 avatar

She, she, she, she’s a BOMBSHELL!!!

More replies
More replies
u/Theeclat avatar

Loveage-Music to Make Love to Your Old Lady By

u/Upstairs_Figure_6836 avatar

Patton is god.

u/kismet-fish avatar

God that album is incredible, such a vibe

u/Theeclat avatar

Still in full rotation here.

More replies

This is it.

More replies

Them Crooked Vultures

We need to push them all for another album!!

I know Dave has said he wants to. Hell, let's get another Probot album while we're at it!

More replies

Came here to say this!

More replies
Edited

You know, just an average rock band, consisting of John Paul Jones (of Led Zeppelin), Dave Grohl (of Nirvana/Foo Fighters), and Josh Homme (of Queens of the Stone Age). No big deal. Also, I just learned that Liam Lynch did the artwork and graphic design for the album, but "Whatever."

More replies
u/RunningInCali avatar

Came here to say this one.

More replies
u/Sun_Records_Fan avatar

The United States Of America - The United States Of America (1968)

Just listened to the album again yesterday, it's unreal how creative and interesting it is to hear

More replies

Temple Of The Dog

Listened to Say Hello to Heaven and cranked it waayyyyyy up today

u/Changetheworld69420 avatar

Hunger Strike is one of the best songs ever made.

More replies
u/eKlectical_Designs avatar

This is the answer - played it over and over

u/Lgprimes avatar

Agree!

This

More replies

Young Marble Giants

Definitely.

More replies

Oysterhead

He used to be the owner of the world, but now he’s just another man who used to be the owner of the world.

u/ChavaLager avatar

When all else has been done and said...

More replies

The La’s - The La’s (1990)

Kinda controversial as it was released without the band’s consent.

More replies
u/Kid_Kameleon avatar

Team Sleep: Self Titled

More replies
[deleted]
[deleted]
Edited

This is cheating a bit, but The Zombies first all-original album was Oracle and Odyssey released in 1967. They had an album before that but it was a lot of covers. Then they didn't release another album until 1991. So I consider Oracle and Odyssey to be their only true original album. And it's incredible.

Edit: it's actually called Odessey and Oracle whoops

Nice. Colin Blumstone's solo stuff is insane too.

TIL they really only had 1 album.

And about a month ago I learned that Rob Zombie was NOT a member of the band.

The Zombies are an awesome band. Time of the Season and She’s Not There often make it into my rotation when playing random music videos on YouTube. Bus Stop by the Hollies and anything Roy Orbison are some more goldies I play a lot.

More replies

I LOVE the Zombies. They still play shows, I’ve seen them a few times and they’re still really good. +10 to O&O.

More replies

Sex Pistols

u/IAmNotScottBakula avatar

This should be the top answer. They aren’t my personal favorite, but it’s hard to name a one-album band that impacted music more.