Quotable Mathematics: On Symbols (2010-)

10 May 2024

On Symbols (2010-)

"In natural language, even the most carefully chosen words drag along concealed meanings that have the power to manipulate reasoning. [...] Symbols of mathematics too sometimes have concealed meanings, but their purpose is to bring along pure thought. It is possible to learn what a mathematical symbol stands for by context. We learn the meanings of mathematical symbols mostly from their definitions: Mostly, because in formal mathematics not everyone easily grasps definitions that are not linked to the familiar properties of experience." (Joseph Mazur, "Enlightening Symbols: A Short History of Mathematical Notation and Its Hidden Powers", 2014)

"Unlike symbols in poetry, mathematical symbols begin as deliberate designs created by mathematicians. That does not stop symbols from performing the same function that a poem would: to make connections between experience and the unknown and to transfer metaphorical thoughts capable of conveying meaning. As in poetry, there are archetypes in mathematics. If there are such things as self-evident truths, then there probably are things we know about the world that come with the human package at birth." (Joseph Mazur, "Enlightening Symbols: A Short History of Mathematical Notation and Its Hidden Powers", 2014)

"What is good mathematical notation? As it is with most excellent questions, the answer is not so simple. Whatever a symbol is, it must function as a revealer of patterns, a pointer to generalizations. It must have an intelligence of its own, or at least it must support our own intelligence and help us think for ourselves. It must be an indicator of things to come, a signaler of fresh thoughts, a clarifier of puzzling concepts, a help to overcome the mental fatigues of confusion that would otherwise come from rhetoric or shorthand." (Joseph Mazur, "Enlightening Symbols: A Short History of Mathematical Notation and Its Hidden Powers", 2014)

"When it comes to algebra, visual conception is beyond any similarities in the physical world. That’s okay; as we’ve noted, it’s not the job of mathematics to be concerned with the physical world, nor with what we call 'reality'. Symbolic consistency and meaning are essentials of mathematics. So is certainty. So is imagination. So is the creative process. So is hypothesis. So is belief beyond experience. So is adventure of knowledge. And, in today’s complexity, there is no better way to do the job of mathematics than by symbolic envisagement." (Joseph Mazur, "Enlightening Symbols: A Short History of Mathematical Notation and Its Hidden Powers", 2014)

"Yet there is a distinct difference between the writer’s art and the mathematician’s. Whereas the writer is at liberty to use symbols in ways that contradict experience in order to jolt emotions or to create states of mind with deep-rooted meanings from a personal life’s journey, the mathematician cannot compose contradictions, aside from the standard argument that establishes a proof by contradiction. Mathematical symbols have a definite initial purpose: to tidily package complex information in order to facilitate understanding." (Joseph Mazur, "Enlightening Symbols: A Short History of Mathematical Notation and Its Hidden Powers", 2014)

"Usually, diagrams contain some noise – information unrelated to the diagram’s primary goal. Noise is decorations, redundant, and irrelevant data, unnecessarily emphasized and ambiguous icons, symbols, lines, grids, or labels. Every unnecessary element draws attention away from the central idea that the designer is trying to share. Noise reduces clarity by hiding useful information in a fog of useless data. You may quickly identify noise elements if you can remove them from the diagram or make them less intense and attractive without compromising the function." (Vasily Pantyukhin, "Principles of Design Diagramming", 2015)

"Using symbols is one common way of applying semantics to help make sense of the world. Symbols provide clues to understanding experiences by conveying recognizable meanings that are shared by societies." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

"When dealing with meaningful visual representation, aspects of a representation's meaning can be altered by modifying its visual characteristics; these characteristics are extensively explored in semiotics, the study of signs and symbols and their use or interpretation." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

No comments:

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

On Symbols (2010-)

"In natural language, even the most carefully chosen words drag along concealed meanings that have the power to manipulate reasoning. [...