Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Careers and Employment | Indeed.com
3.5 out of 5 stars.
Write a review

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Careers and Employment

About the company

  • CEO
    Benedikt Sander
    61%
    approve of Benedikt Sander's performance
  • Founded
    1896
  • Company size
    201 to 500
  • Revenue
    $100M to $500M (USD)
  • Industry
  • Headquarters
    New Berlin, NY Norwich, ...
  • Link
    Preferred Mutual Insurance Company website

While it's preferable that nothing ever go wrong, Preferred Mutual Insurance would rather you be safe than sorry. Preferred Mutual provides personal and commercial lines of property/casualty insurance to policyholders in New York, as well as in Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and New Jersey. The company primarily writes automobile and homeowners insurance; other offerings include commercial umbrella, business owners, identity theft, specialty vehicle, and specialty dwelling policies. Some 400 inde...

While it's preferable that nothing ever go wrong, Preferred Mutual Insurance would rather you be safe than sorry. Preferred Mutual provides personal and commercial lines of property/casualty insurance to policyholders in New York, as well as in Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and New Jersey. The company primarily writes automobile and homeowners insurance; other offerings include commercial umbrella, business owners, identity theft, specialty vehicle, and specialty dwelling policies. Some 400 independent agencies sells the company's products. Preferred Mutual Insurance was founded in 1896 as a New York mutual fire insurance firm and is owned by its policyholders.

Learn more

Jobs

We were not able to detect your location. You can browse through all 10 jobs Preferred Mutual Insurance Company has to offer

Job Card
Job Card1 of 2
Full-time
Contact Center Representative I - Hybrid

United States

$17.00 - $21.25 an hour
Easily apply

30+ days ago

View job
Full-time
Business Services Representative I - Personal Lines Rater (Remote)

New Berlin, NY

$17.00 - $21.25 an hour

10 days ago

View job
Full-time
Senior Internal Auditor (Remote-Northeast)

United States

$87,665.09 - $137,117.19 a year
Easily apply

24 days ago

View job
Full-time
Material Damage Virtual Estimator - REMOTE (Northeast Only)

United States

$58,500 - $73,000 a year
Easily apply

23 days ago

View job

Browse jobs by location

New Berlin, NY

4 jobs

Salaries

Salary estimated from 30 employees, users, and past and present job advertisements on Indeed.

Benefits

Employees at Preferred Mutual Insurance Company have reported receiving these benefits. They will vary by role and location.

Health insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
Paid time off
Retirement plan
Flexible schedule
Health savings account
Tuition reimbursement
Flexible spending account
Employee assistance program
Parental leave
Life insurance
Professional development assistance

Rating overview

Rating is calculated based on 40 reviews and is evolving.

4.86 out of 5 stars.20202.00 out of 5 stars.20215.00 out of 5 stars.20223.33 out of 5 stars.2023

Reviews

Adjuster in New York State
on April 6, 2023
Very old school , family environment. Archaic claims system . Benefits awful . Pay is commensurate with your experience. Good time off . Set in their ways and not willing to get out of the Stone Age with claims processes
Anonymous in New York State
on July 31, 2023
The company was better before they stopped using the Eagle as the brand insignia. It feels like things are deteriorating. They tell us we are improving, yet we can’t get simple office supplies.
Customer Service Representative in New Berlin, NY
on February 11, 2023
I came to the company in May 2022 and have never looked back. I am valued, supported, encouraged, and have been given so many opportunities. Preferred Mutual is a company like no other I have worked for, they see my potential and I truly feel like such an asset. I have also taken advantage of the schooling they provide, it’s online, at your own pace, and definitely helps with advancement opportuni...
PMO Project Manager in New Berlin, NY
on October 12, 2022
What is the best part of working at the company?They really care about their employees and are VERY pet friendly!!What is the most stressful part about working at the company?Smaller company, less opportunity for growth/development/movement within the org.What is the work environment and culture like at the company?Fantastic. People are salt of the earth, hard working, and family oriented....
Liability Claims Representative in New Berlin, NY
on July 9, 2022
Super nice people , small company, enjoyed my time working in claims. Even though I worked remotely, it is sort of a close family-like working environment.

What would you say about your employer?

Help fellow job seekers by sharing your unique experience.

Questions and answers

People have asked 17 questions about working at Preferred Mutual Insurance Company. See the answers, explore popular topics and discover unique insights from Preferred Mutual Insurance Company employees.

Popular questions

See questions about:

  • Benefits
  • Hiring Process
  • Interviews
  • Working Environment
  • Promotion
  • Working Culture
  • CEO
  • Health benefits
  • Working Hours

Interview insights

Insights from 15 Indeed users who have interviewed with Preferred Mutual Insurance Company within the last 5 years.

Favorable experience
Interview is average
Process takes about a month

Common questions about Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

Working at Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

  • Manager3.0 out of 5 stars.
  • Claims Representative4.3 out of 5 stars.
  • Service Technician3.0 out of 5 stars.
  • Human Resources Specialist5.0 out of 5 stars.

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company locations

What's being discussed at Preferred Mutual Insurance Company?

Select a topic to see what people are saying about different issues

  • Companies
  • Insurance
  • Preferred Mutual Insurance Company